Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
44 of 48 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Gardner's best effort to date, January 27, 2005
Bobby Dodge, member of the elite STOP team in Boston, MA, which deals with dangerous police situations, has just completed a grim task: as a sniper he has ended the life of a husband Jimmy Gagnon, who seemingly was on the verge of harming either his wife Catherine or his son Nathan. And to add to Bobby's distress at having to kill another man, he is immediately attacked by Jimmy's father, Judge James Gagnon, a powerful Boston personage, for acting rashly and caving in to the manipulations of Catherine.
But what is it about the past of Bobby, Catherine, and Jimmy, and even the Judge, that has led to this point? Lisa Gardner expertly combines the unfolding of traumatic disturbances in their lives with rapid fire developments in the present. Given her history, could Catherine, one with elegant, fragile beauty, orchestrate her own husband's death? Maybe Bobby knew more about the Gagnon's then he is telling - are his actions completely innocent? Why is the Judge's and his wife's past shrouded in mystery?
This is Lisa Gardner's best book, and most of her previous books were quite good. The plot is great and it moves. Yet the characters get the right amount of attention. And there are some nice twists. This latest effort by Gardner will disappoint few.
|
|
|
27 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
"Alone" has it all: abuse, lust, murder, revenge and healing, February 6, 2005
"Alone", by Lisa Gardner, NY, Bantam, 2004 ISBN 0-553-80253-4 (hc), 324 p., by author of 6 prior NYT best-selling novels (plus 13 others under a.k.a. Alicia Scott). Gardner at her finest renders a suspense novel entwining lives of police sniper Bobby Dodge and Boston socialite Catherine Gagnon with those messed-up lives of their ovn parents and "lustmord" of pedophilist Richard Umbrio. So yes, there's rape abduction, police homicides, and an escalating mess of murder by knife, hanging?, gun -- by chilling variant divating means.
We are immersed into finely-tuned and researched machinations of SWAT techniques, of alleged spousal & child abuse, of aftermath of incest, pedophilia and inappropriate use of financial and judicial power, and importantly a heartening and occasionally disheartening look into survival techniques used by people suffering from imperfections and fragility of the human condition and where the bottom line rings true that blood runs thicker than thieves.
Gardner's command of language, be it technical, romantic, carnal, or merely weaving fact with fiction is simply superb -- when novels get this good it is hard to say enough and I'd love to have a signed copy. Deservedly, I give it 5***** without hesitation.
|
|
|
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Apparently, I'm in the minority..., June 15, 2005
but I hated this book. I always look forward to a Lisa Gardner book, but this one was a great disappointment. First off, I hated the heroine Catherine (if that's what you can call her). I realize she had a traumatic experience as a child, but she grew up to be an unlikeable woman. She manipulates, cheats, sets up an innocent police officer and is very unapologetic about it. The whole book overall is depressing. You like to see a little bit of hope or happiness in a novel, but this has none of that. The police officer is suspended, oh, and he also had an abusive childhood, and don't forget he's an alcoholic, oh, and let's not forget her childhood tragedy, and her postpartum depression, and how she was willing to just hand off her kid to a nanny, oh, and her kid is sick and her husband is abusive and her in-laws are awful...I could go on and on. I did like the hero Bobby, and I did have hope that he would end up happy, and he kind of did, except he walked away from the woman he loved and never went back. Great. And the tragedy continues. The story ends with the police still trying to get Catherine. I actually skipped parts of the book because I thought it just all seemed so unreal. I kept waiting for it to get better, but it never did. I like heart-wrenching stories, but I just didn't care enough about the characters to shed a single tear. I'm hoping her next novel isn't this bad.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|