Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Solid Story, August 6, 2001
It was nice going back to read this story. Copyright 1996, it shows beautifully the Voyager crew as they were at that time. Certainly, we've learned new things about the characters as the seasons progressed, and later novels reflect this, but these first efforts should not be dismissed just because they may not fit what we now know.Besides, this one was chock full of references to Chakotay's Native American heritage, which was, in fact, integral to the plot - something sorely lacking in the show after about the second season. For this reason (and also because it's still a Kes-inclusive story), it's worth the read. Okay, so the plot was a teensy bit predictable (two alien races at war, with a big secret between them), but why is that bad? This is a Star Trek tale, ferheavensake, it doesn't have to be the world's greatest novel. It just has to be a lively and entertaining ensemble story that makes me feel good at the end. Spot on for me, my friends!
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
disappointing to say the least, June 27, 1998
I'm a real Voyager fan, but I was very disappointed reading this book. I remember looking up from my book every half hour or so, and telling myself to keep on reading, not to give up on Voyager. On the whole I found it "flat". Flat in characterisation and shallow in plotline. There can be much more made of this book when you really start working on it's possibilities on the exploration of planets, cultural changes during millenia, religious depth and goasts, being evil usurpors, slavery, wormholes, loyalty versus madeness. The story touches all these wonderful elements, but never gets to explore them in a better way then is done in a childrens book: easy and shallow....And then there are those major plot-damaging inconsistencies. One of the major points is that the "slave race" never has seen the face of their usurpors. But on the other hand they have their technology copied, because one of the evil ships crashed on the planets surface.... What was nice was the crossreverence to the series, to things happened in the Voyagers past. It really was our crew that way.But what I really hated was her getting into Janeways head, making her a bit of an neurotic women, with a rather typical set of values and attitudes for instance on bravery and keeping up appearences. I'm not sure if I'm allowed to quote passages (copywrite and such things) so I'd better not, sorry. On the whole I think this book was an easy ride for the aut! hor. It has all the characteristics of a having-to-pay-the-rent-quickie. And yes: we fans we are known to be loyal buyers of spin-off of our series, so we even "buy" these things (in both senses of the word). I don't want to give up on Voyager books altogether, but I sure hope the others are better.
|
|
|
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
This book is not worth reading, January 3, 1999
By A Customer
as soon as you start reading this book, you'll find out that the auther has very limited knowledge about astro-science, as well as basic startrek-science concepts, not to mention the characterization and the plotline. I am a loyal fan of Voyager, however, I found this book difficult to accept for the reason that both the characterization and the concept of science are illogical. My conclusion is, this book is not worth reading, in fact, it will make you more confused about everything in ST Voyager.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|