Einstein and Oppenheimer: The Meaning of Genius (Hardcover)

by Silvan S. Schweber (Author)

Editorial Reviews

From Booklist
*Starred Review* Typically viewed as solitary geniuses, the two most prominent scientists of twentieth-century America—Einstein and Oppenheimer—here appear in their defining social contexts. Einstein may have achieved remarkable feats in the apparent isolation of a Swiss patent office. Yet Schweber deflates the myth of the iconoclastic loner, detailing the revolutionary’s extensive debt to the community of European researchers. Schweber’s insightful narrative indeed reveals how Einstein’s subsequent reliance upon his unaided talents left him stranded in sterile theorizing, cut off from the collaboration of younger colleagues exploring quantum mechanics. As one of those colleagues, Oppenheimer captured the limelight as the director of the Manhattan Project, a position awarded him because of the leadership he had already demonstrated in fusing the diverse talents of pioneering scientists at Berkeley. But the publicly triumphant Oppenheimer delved deep in Vedic scripture and American Pragmatism trying to quell self-doubts born of his ambivalent Jewishness and his costly tardiness in reaching the frontiers of physics. Schweber finally confronts readers with ruptures in both men’s public lives, as Einstein breaks with institutions resistant to his personal imperatives and Oppenheimer self-destructs in the glare of a security-clearance hearing. Those interested in the history of culture will learn much from these parallel dramas illuminating the oft-neglected social dynamics of science. --Bryce Christensen

Review
You'd be forgiven for thinking there is little we don't know already about Einstein and Oppenheimer. Yet this book plots the lives of the 20th century's most charismatic physicists to a greater end than biography. Focusing on the cultural milieus in which they thrived, Schweber investigates Einstein and Oppenheimer's very different manifestations of genius--one solitary, one social. Schweber's depth of analysis, particularly in describing both scientists' affinities for Buddhist thought, insists that there is much more to learn about each. (Seed 20080522)

The real interest of Mr. Schweber's account--and what makes his dual biography unusual--is the emphasis he places not on Einstein's or Oppenheimer's scientific achievements, which have been often enough described, but on their later careers, when both found themselves, for different reasons, strangely sidelined.
--Eric Ormsby (New York Sun 20080901)

Schweber has set himself quite a task in seeking to add to our understanding [of Einstein and Oppenheimer]. By my reckoning he has succeeded, not so much by uncovering significant new material as by reflecting wisely and eloquently on Einstein's and Oppenheimer's politics, their relationships with their colleagues, and their contributions to science.
--Lawrence Black (Times Higher Education Supplement 20090201)

Have we not heard enough of these two men? Yet Silvan S. Schweber shows us in his new book, Einstein and Oppenheimer, that there is still more to say. What we know about these two giants of physics largely concerns their genius--their formidable mental powers--but this focus tends to foreground the individual at the expense of intellectual and scientific context. Schweber's aim is ambitious: to capture another quality that he calls the greatness of Einstein and Oppenheimer--to show how their actions altered humanity's "ideas concerning what human beings can be or do." We know much about the genius of these two men, Schweber implies, but little of their greatness.
--Robert P. Crease (American Scientist )

In a brief review, it is not possible to do full justice to Schweber's probing book, which merits careful reading.
--Michael W. Friedlander (Physics World )

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 432 pages
• Publisher: Harvard University Press (April 30, 2008)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0674028287
• ISBN-13: 978-0674028289
• Product Dimensions: 9.1 x 6.3 x 1.4 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.5 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 4.0 out of 5 stars See all reviews (4 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #369,776 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

  Popular in these categories: (What's this?)

  #6 in	Books > Science > Physics > Nuclear Physics > Atomic Physics
  #23 in	Books > Biographies & Memoirs > People, A-Z > ( E ) > Einstein, Albert

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

2.0 out of 5 stars A Very Difficult Read, December 30, 2008

By	Diane P. Johnson - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

This is a very interesting book, but it is very challenging to read if you do not know more than high school physics. There is a lot of discussion about theory, but no explanation of the theories. It needed a little "dumbing down" of the physics to make it more comprehensible. It also presumes a lot of knowledge about both Einstein & Oppenheimer. For example the author states as fact that Oppenheimer lost his security clearance & the career path results, but doesn't detail how this security clearance loss came about.
When not discussing physics, the book is interesting in its discussion of the men and their interest in philosophy, and in comparing & contrasting the men in many ways. There is also a lot of interesting information on Los Alamos and WWII & post WWII politics about the bombs.

5 of 8 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars GENIUS, September 5, 2008

By	Dr. Nuclear Physicist "PHOTOPHYSICIST" (TEXAS) - See all my reviews

THE AUTHOR HAS BEEN COMPILING A BIOGRAPHY OF HANS BETHE. HE HAS PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED A BOOK COMPARING OPPENHEIMER AND BETHE. DURING THIS TIME HE HAS DONE EXTENSIVE RESEARCH ON MANY PROMINENT PHYSICISTS WHOM BETHE HAS INTERACTED WITH (SOME WHO THE AUTHOR KNEW QUITE WELL). THE WORD "GENIUS" HAS BEEN APPLIED TO MOST OF THESE MEN AT ONE TIME OR ANOTHER.

ONE MAY NOT AGREE WITH ALL THE AUTHOR'S CONCLUSIONS. BUT THESE CONCLUSIONS ARE BASED ON EXTENSIVE RESEARCH AND THOUGHT. IF NOTHING ELSE, THEY SHOULD STIMULATE YOUR THOUGHT PROCESSES AND OPEN UP A NEW HORIZON.

RECENTLY THERE HAVE BEEN MANY BOOKS ON EINSTEIN AND ON OPPENHEIMER, BOTH COMPLEX MEN FROM THE VIEW POINT OF US MORTALS HOWEVER THIS BOOK IS UNIQUE IN ITS COVERAGE AND INSIGHTFUL COMPARISONS

1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars Interesting yet challenging., January 14, 2009

By	Seth Lefferts "Peace Activist" (Bethel, CT USA) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

Whereas this book is an excellent insight to both of these iconic figures it does require a basic understanding of the principles of quantum physics, atomic fission and fusion to be fully appreciated. However, the point of this book to me is to understand the effects of the militaristic use of the 'new science' on these two men and how it changed their lives. That is wonderfully written and that makes this book a must read.