|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Chilling, December 31, 2002
By A Customer
Before going into my own thoughts on this book, I would like to respond to an earlier reviewer who found this an obviously fictional account because:"Basically, in atomic research you need lots of industrial equipment, like the South African and Israeli governments bought or developed(from other advanced nations). Iraq has nothing close to this." To this I say: North Korea, Pakistan, India (and coming soon, Iran) -- and ??? In this I do not mean to disparage the countries named, but they clearly do not fall within that reviewers idea of a highly developed industrialized "Big 5" nation. What Iraq was not able to develop on its own, it WAS able to buy. And that last is really one of the main themes of this book. The ability of Iraq to buy, and the willingness of others to sell, everything that Iraq needs -- for a price. This brought to mind Bernard Lewis's accounts in "Islam and the West" in which the West was more than willing to sell modern arms to Islamic states in the distant past. But I digress. Dr. Hamzah portrays/is portrayed as a man caught up in a combination of greed, ego, and fear. He was finally able to extricate himself and his family (and his accounts of his difficulties dealing with the CIA do not bode well for the future). His description of how easily he was ensnared in this gilded cage, one step at a time, is truly a cautionary tale. At the same time, his detailed description of how a rogue state can go about obtaining the necessary ingredients for a nuclear and other weapons of mass destruction) weapon is dismaying to say the least. But at least it takes a LOT of money. The one element that did not ring true (for me)was Dr. Hamza's description of his poker playing. He clearly knows very little about poker, and writing of his exploits as someone who does (even marginally) gave me pause. But it is more along the lines of grandiosity than outright fabrication. And that is perhaps the best way to approach this book. Accept that Dr. Hamza (for various reasons) puffs himself up a bit -- but that is also what made him more susceptible to Saddam's enticements Well worth reading if you want to understand how Iraq could get a weapons program going, and maintain it in secrecy despite attempts to uncover it. Also a worthwhile study of how a man can slowly slip into a bad situation through greed, and hubris.
|