From Publishers Weekly
Walking a thin line between the witty and the precious, comedian DeLuise brings an ebullient, jaunty style to this version of "The Emperor's New Clothes." He moves the story along briskly while conveying just enough worldly sophistication to flatter a young audience: describing the magical cloth that "only the pure of heart could see," for example, DeLuise says in an aside, "Can you imagine anyone believing such a thing?" But the author brings a heavy hand to his delivery of what he sees as the tale's moral: setting the right priorities in life. Priorities, he intones, "are those things in your life that are most precious to you, like being kind to your friends and yourself; eating healthily; getting enough sleep; brushing your teeth"?and the list goes on. Fortunately, Santoro (previously paired with DeLuise for Goldilocks) never falters in his comically exaggerated illustrations. Their remarkable energy borders on animation, and children will be tickled by the sight of the chubby, flamboyantly mustachioed king (who boasts a chin to rival Jay Leno's) caught in nothing but his birthday clothes. (Lest the modesty-minded grow anxious, the king's enormous sagging paunch does double duty as a fig leaf). Four fairly simple "royal" recipes that parents and children can make together are appended. Ages 4-8.
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 2-3-In this didactic remake of "The Emperor's New Clothes," sartorially extravagant King Discombobulated-Bob for short-buys into the promises of smooth-talking tailors Wear and Tear Kannive until a peasant lad opens his eyes (and hands him a horse blanket). From an opening sermon on personal priorities to King Bob's closing admission that his values have been all mixed up, DeLuise loses few opportunities to moralize, or to explain the nature of each character and the meaning of each statement. Except that the naked king seems to have lost his private parts, Santoro's Disneyesque cartoons leave little to readers' imagination; each detail and personality is evenly, brightly lit and obvious. In the end, the Kannives are forgiven and set to making clothes for the poor, and readers get the double bonus of a "Priority List" ("Telling the truth"; "Doing your homework") and four simplified royal recipes, including "King Crown Cake." Andersen's original tale is available in several picture book editions; for an updated version, try Stephanie Calmenson's The Principal's New Clothes (Scholastic, 1989).
John Peters, New York Public LibraryCopyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
See all Editorial Reviews