From School Library Journal
Grade 3-5-This handsome, well-researched picture book introduces John Harrison, the 18th-century English carpenter turned clockmaker who spent more than 40 years perfecting a device that solved the centuries-old problem of determining longitude. Beginning with Harrison's childhood, Borden presents biographical tidbits that bring the man to life, show how he differed from "most other village folk," and set the scene for his later accomplishments. With no formal training in clock making, he followed his instincts and used trial and error to build innovative timepieces. The narrative next describes the difficulties involved in determining east/west positioning at sea, explaining that captains could calculate longitude if they had an accurate shipboard timekeeper (a task impossible for 18th-century pendulum clocks). The prize offered by Parliament for a solution to the problem is also mentioned. The rest of the book details Harrison's dedication, perseverance, and ingenuity, as he struggled to build and perfect an accurate sea clock and fought to have his invention acknowledged by the Board of Longitude. The writing has a measured pace that helps readers to keep the details straight and the scientific concepts are clearly explained and smoothly incorporated into the text. Blegvad's precise illustrations create a strong sense of time and place. Alternating between black-and-white sketches and watercolor paintings, the pictures show Harrison hard at work, offer close-ups of his various inventions, and provide glimpses of his England. Taking a slightly different approach and providing more depth, this book makes a solid companion to Kathryn Lasky's The Man Who Made Time Travel (Farrar, 2003).
Joy Fleishhacker, School Library JournalCopyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Gr. 2-4. Like Kathleen Lasky's
The Man Who Made Time Travel [BKL Mr 1 03], this handsome picture book biography recasts the story made famous by Dava Sobel's
Longitude (1995) in terms children can enjoy
. In unintimidating free verse, Borden narrates the life of John Harrison, the village clockmaker who invented the chronometer--an accurate "sea clock" that allows captains to ascertain their longitude and avoid veering off course--and then spent decades fighting for recognition. The text reads beautifully but sometimes risks oversimplification ("[he] had more courage than all the pompous astronomers and mathematicians put together") and is occasionally vague (Borden explains that Harrison's clock had no pendulum, but doesn't say what it used instead). Blegvad's artwork charmingly depicts Harrison's eighteenth-century milieu, though more direct support of the content may have been warranted. Young readers will nonetheless find plenty to inspire them in this scientific Cinderella story; however, many may reach for Lasky's version first for its more appealing title and Hawkes' illustrations, which favor the dramatic over the picturesque.
Jennifer MattsonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
See all Editorial Reviews