Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Long-Overdue Unmasking of Holocaust Myths, June 13, 2006
Holocaust education in western societies has favored the minimizing of the Polish agony during WWII, and has spawned a large body of misconceptions regarding Polish-Jewish relationships during this tragic time. This profusely-documented work goes a long way towards clarifying these issues. It covers the time from the German-Soviet conquest of Poland to the western-acquiesced imposition of the Soviet puppet government (1939-1947), and is centered on the rural population of the county of Janow Lubelski.
Against the view that Poles were "spectators" of the Jewish catastrophe, the reader immediately realizes that Poles had no possible luxury of being spectators. They too were in a battle of survival, being subject to a progressive genocide consisting of episodic mass murder and universal pauperization. Few realize that, alongside the 5-6 million Jews, a total of 2-3 non-Jewish Poles were murdered by the Germans, as were a few hundred thousand by the Soviet "allies". Nor were German crimes limited to "Nazified formations", as some contemporary German authors claim. For example, the murder of Polish civilian hostages in reprisal for any act of disobedience originated with the German army (p. 92), not the SS or Gestapo.
Various Polish actions, simplistically blamed on "Polish anti-Semitism", usually had other causes. Prewar Polish-Jewish antagonisms, stereotypically attributed to church teachings, were actually fueled primarily by economic rivalry (p. 51-55, 64). Peasants' acceptance of the blood libel must be contextualized within the large body of peasant superstitions, most of which had nothing to do with religion or ethnicity (p. 63). Any conflation of Polish Catholic nationalism with fascism and Nazism is demonstrably false. In fact, even the most right-wing Poles almost universally repudiated the materialistic, racialist, statist, totalitarian, and genocidal character of the latter (p. 56, 339-340).
German documents from October 1941 complain that Poles are not opposing the movements of fugitive Jews within the county (p. 174). There is no evidence of Polish Underground collaboration with Germans against Jews (p. 326) . Slanderous accusations of the Polish Underground (AK, NSZ, and successor organizations) having a secret plan to "finish Hitler's work" by killing all remaining Polish Jews is refuted by such things as the acceptance of known Jews into Underground ranks (p. 179), the sparing of Jews who fell into Underground hands (p. 307), and acts of assistance to fugitive Jews by the Underground (p. 317). The competition of Polish guerilla units against each other for scarce firearms (p. 185) illuminates the unwillingness of the Polish Underground to provide more arms to the Jewish Warsaw ghetto fighters.
The Blue police have incorrectly been portrayed as the Polish counterpart to Ukrainian and Baltic collaborationist forces used in the Holocaust. In actuality, it was a compulsory force set up by the Germans for crime fighting and was hardly ever used for mass executions or the guarding of labor camps (p. 71). Although sometimes used against Jews, the Blue police was not, willingly or unwillingly, responsible for many Jewish deaths (p. 153). Some members of the Blue police aided Jews (p. 174), and a large fraction of its ranks doubled as members of the Polish Underground (p. 194, 222).
The Blue police and low-level Polish civilian administration were not, individual exceptions aside, collaborators. They were primarily accommodators to German terror and hostages of the same (p. 78, 80).
Fugitive Jews formed bands and robbed and killed Polish peasants, and joined subversive Communist units, sometimes provoking Polish counter-actions (p. 149). Otherwise, the sporadic killings of fugitive Jews by Poles was just part of the general lawlessness under a brutal German occupant (p. 154). Complaints about Poles not protecting fugitive Jews from Polish criminals ignore the fact that only a small percentage of even Pole-on-Pole crimes could eventuate Polish anti-criminal intervention (p. 94).
Poles had been willing, despite the draconian German occupation, to risk the death penalty in forming a flourishing black market and setting up Underground units. This has led Jan Thomas Gross to the absurd argument that Poles were therefore not deterred by the death penalty from saving many more Jews. In reality, the black market owed its success to its flexible, spontaneous, mobile, and decentralized nature (p. 122)-in most ways the OPPOSITE of hiding Jews, especially on a large, organized scale. Also, Jan Thomas Gross should know that concealing a Jew was much riskier than blending into the population while a member of the Underground. The considerable German success in arresting members of the Polish underground (p. 192) underscores the risk of even Underground involvement, and makes folly of the argument that Poles should have saved many more Jews. Finally, the relevance of the death penalty in constraining Polish conduct is proved by the fact that the Underground carefully planned its actions to minimize German reprisals against Poles (p. 337).
Some 300 out of about 1,000 fugitive local Jews did survive the Holocaust (p. 326), a fraction comparable to that of Warsaw's fugitive Jews (Paulsson. SECRET CITY). These figures soundly refute the claim that a fugitive Jew was almost certain to be betrayed by a Pole. Application of Paulsson's simple arithmetic makes it obvious that, unless Polish denouncers of Jews had been very uncommon, hardly any fugitive Jew could have survived. The Germans did boast of having "two informers per village" (p. 119) relevant to Pole-on-Pole denunciations, so it appears that these were at least as common as Pole-on-Jew denouncers.
About 4% of local Poles assisted Jews in some way (p. 152), and complaints that "most Poles did nothing" ignore the fact that the vast majority of Poles were never approached by even a single fugitive Jew for help (p. 153)! The Holocaust itself was so unexpected and so swiftly applied that few Jews could even plan to escape the urban ghettos and seek Polish help (p. 151, 153). THAT, and not imagined Polish indifference or hostility, was the REAL reason for only a small percentage of Polish Jews surviving the Holocaust! It is high time that Holocaust materials reflect this reality.
|
|
|
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
WORTH EVERY DOLLAR - PRICEY, BUT NOT A BETTER BOOK ON THIS TOPIC,I.E., SHOWS GREAT OBJECTIVITY,BALANCE AND CONTROL - REGAL/SOLID, August 30, 2008
The only book you will ever need on this topic. There are many books on this topic that misinform you and confuse everyone as to what the truth is. Start with this book, and go from there. Chodakiewicz is nothing less than research Royalty, and more importantly: He tells the Truth, which is a refreshing change. Every WWII enthusiast and holocaust reader "must," have this book, to really learn anything - PERIOD.
|
|
|
|
