|
39 of 48 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting premise but flawed, December 19, 2003
I was looking forward to this book as I had not read many simulations showing a war between China and Taiwan. The scenario is fascinating and daring and is a generally fluid read. The beginning of the book moves quickly and pulls you effortlessly along. Of course events of the last two years have made this scenario a bit more unlikely but these guys don't claim to be seers, they're writing a story that among other things gives a good idea of how alot of military equipment works.Yet, the book contains several flaws that grate. First, the characters are generally bland, one dimensional people that are hard to relate to. The "good guys" are pure good, they do everything right all the time and always seem to know what is actually happening. The "bad" guys are pure evil, always plotting and schemeing. The good characters are almost flawless while the bad have absolutely no redeeming virtue whatsoever. Not only is this fairly unrealistic but it gets tedious. Many people are not black and white and to have a book full of them gets old fast. When you start a scene with Character X, you pretty much know what they're going to be up to and what they're going to be about. The dialogue coming from their mouths was also quite predictable. Second, the book seems to have been written by a pair of Clinton-haters. While never calling him out by name, the author spends no little time doing everything possible to show that Bill Clinton was an utter traitor and despicable human being on all levels. Say what you want, think what you want, but this book went way over the top on that angle to the point of silliness and yes, tediousness. I began to think that if Clinton were really this bad then the military was run by fools for continuing to obey him. The book skipped around in time in a rather herky-jerky fashion. For instance, the first few chapters focused on a meeting that lasted a few days. Then all of a sudden months pass but you're not told this immediately, you have to figure it out from the reading! Then the Chinese invade Taiwan and it almost gets down to a minute by minute play by play, and then speeds up again and the authors skip over a few days in the space of a paragraph! While wasting time on a boring & tepid romance (between a 27 year old CIA analyst and a 51 year old father figure general) the Taiwanese were marshalling a counterattack and the Cinese nuked them with neutron devices. That however got a small mention as there was "love" in the air. C'mon! I didn't read this for a poorly worded, implausible, and boring romance! The authors would focus on the nitty gritty of certain things (like the love story) that offered little but then offhandedly refer to major events happening in the background. The Marine Unit that fought to defend Taiwan for several days gets evacuated, but we don't get the details, we just happen to hear about it. No word on how (since the authors told us there were no US Navy surface assets nearby) or why or anything like that, just that one day, they were gone! They started an interesting thread about an LA class sub sinking some shipping in the straits between Taiwan and China but then stopped mentioning it. Did it get sunk? Was it recalled? Where did it go? One minute the sub has half the Chinese navy after it and then they just stop discussing it. What about the XO of the Marine unit (a stereotypical "bad" guy who was given no redeeming qualities)? He started out as a regular character but then vanishes halfway through. Did he die? Did he do something right? Was he relieved? What happened? I did finish the book and in spite of the flaws I did enjoy much of it. But the flaws are major and the writing is generally poor. If you can look past that or aren't looking for much complexity this is fine but you're not getting Tom Clancy here, nowhere close.
|