From Publishers Weekly
This follow-up to Mapson's popular Bad Girl Creek introduces a new face to the spirited gang of hard-luck women running a California flower farm. Mary Madigan ("Maddy") Caringella is a rodeo performer who decides to leave her job (and her boozy singing partner and boyfriend) and travel across the country, taking part in karaoke competitions. In Oklahoma City, she hooks up with Rick Heinrich, a fiercely independent middle-aged journalist. While the two are in New Mexico, they meet Beryl Anne, an ex--Bad Girl who's now touring the country with her guitarist beau. In various ways, Maddy and Rick's lives become entwined with the lives of the women of Bad Girl Creek, and eventually they make their way to the farm itself, encountering some rough patches in their relationship along the way. The book is told in the voices of several characters, primarily Maddy, Rick, Beryl and Phoebe, the founder of the flower farm-she is now pregnant and facing a life-threatening delivery. Mapson gives updates on other Bad Girls as well: Ness is learning to live with HIV and Nance is fighting her anorexia, even as she plans a wedding to Phoebe's brother, James, and pines for her old love. Maddy is an appealingly saucy protagonist, though her voice gradually loses its distinctiveness and blends with that of the other narrators (who tend to sound alike) as the book wears on. The story is as sentimental as its precursor, but those who enjoyed the female bonding and entrepreneurial antics of the Bad Girls will be pleased with this chatty sequel. Literary Guild and Doubleday Book Club alternate.
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Fans of Bad Girl Creek will no doubt enjoy reuniting with Phoebe, now pregnant and grieving for her fianc , killed on their wedding day; Ness, who appears to be in remission from AIDS; Beryl Anne, totally in love with Earl, the perfect man, but still dealing with the emotional scars from her time in jail for accidentally killing her husband; and Nancy, engaged to Phoebe's brother James but struggling with a serious eating disorder. They will also enjoy meeting the new (and equally damaged) characters, who include Rick, a 50-year-old writer who's never grown up and, coincidentally, was a primary cause of Nancy's anorexia, and Mary Madigan, an alcoholic singer mourning her twin sister's death in the Oklahoma City bombing. But newcomers to Mapson will be in for a disappointment. Melodrama abounds (this is like an old-timey radio soap opera), and the novel also suffers from being told from multiple viewpoints; as it is, the characters are paper-thin, and with so many of them crowding the pages, it's nearly impossible to distinguish one voice from another. This is definitely not Mapson's best book (that would be Blue Rodeo) and should be purchased only for demand.
--Nancy Pearl, Washington Ctr. for the Book, Seattle Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
See all Editorial Reviews