Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable DS9 Characters, but fragmented plot..., September 19, 2001
I've been following the books that continue the story of DS9 past the point of the final episode in the TV Series, and I've been really enjoying them. For one, there's the more "Serial" nature to them: the new DS9 books don't always end with everything wrapped up that was introduced (indeed, Jake has been missing somewhere inside the wormhole for a few books now). For another, there's the lack of "reset" to the books: most of the Star Trek books can't change anything major, as the characters would show these changes thereafter in the series, whereas with the DS9 books, now that the series is over, this isn't the case. All of that said, the plot in this book was very fragmented. I realize it is one of the books in a series, but standing alone, parts of it didn't even make sense: The Iconians have come back, is the premise, and they've opened up all their old doorways in space as almost an example to the quadrant over what they're selling to the highest bidder, but some Malon antimatter waste is coming through one of those gateways, ruining a planet nearby DS9. So, the story is basically a rescue attempt from DS9. Unfortunately, the other plot wrinkles all suffer from a stutter: you have a lot of cliffhangers in the end of this book, and yet nearly nothing is resolved at all. I don't mind a "serial," but to give me nothing completed is something else. Also, given that a lot of the readers of the DS9 books aren't going to go pick up five other books just so that the DS9 book in this series makes sense, and you've got a problem with this one. There was quite a bit of merit in the book: the exploration of what's going on with Dax was interesting, and you get quite a bit more character development from Shar, the new ensign science officer for DS9. Still, both of these didn't quite save the book entirely for me, and I was let down. If you do want to keep reading the DS9 books that are set after the series, this one is necessary, as Dax and Shar have some important revelations, but in and of itself, the novel doesn't stand alone, and you may find that to really enjoy it, you'll need the other books in the "Gateways" series. 'Nathan
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Dynamite!, August 28, 2001
Warning. Once you pick up this book you will find it hard to put down. Exciting, fast moving with wonderful characterizations and a fantastic story. Definately the stand out in the Gateways series so far. And if you are not reading the others you can still enjoy this great DS9 adventure. For those who've been reading the relaunch novels this story follows right on the heels of "Abyss" Been wondering what's up with Shar? Been anxious to learn more about Vaughn? Well "Demons of Air and Darkness" fills in more of the pieces and does a great job of advancing all the characters while still telling a great stand alone story. The book is full of surprises that I don't want to give away but for anyone looking for a great read full of adventure and great characters I highly recommend this book.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Nice Plot, But The Writing Should Have Been Better, October 11, 2004
The previous reviews did excellent jobs in covering the plot of this novel. I want to point out some things about the writing, though.
DeCandido is a good Star Trek writer. But he falls into the same trap that many other (and more mediocre) Trek novelists fall into -- making the characters little more than 20th century people living in the 23rd/24th centuries.
Trek novelists can produce great works -- witness Andrew Robinson's great "A Stitch In Time," or some of Diane Carey's books. They are true to the Trek universe without taking shortcuts in writing.
In "Demons," DeCandido takes the easy way out in writing much of the character's speech. For example, three pages in, the Malon, about whom little has been written or seen in previous Trek incarnations, and about whom much new thought could be given, speak like they are just a bunch of current-day (20th century) humans. Would they really say "dam*it?" And couldn't DeCandido come up with anything more novel than that?
Would an Orion slavegirl say "harebrained scheme?" Would she even know what a "hare" is?
Would a Starship captain refer to her ship as "wicked efficient?" She would if she grew up where I grew up, south of Boston, in the late 20th century. But I doubt that she did.
These are just three top-of-mind examples. Listen. The book was okay -- nothing spectacular, just typical Trek "these 12 characters that you all know and love are going to save the universe -- yes, the universe -- yet again." It's written like an extended DS:9 episode. And that's not necessarily a bad thing.
I just wish that DeCandido -- and other many Trek authors -- would put a little more thought into how the characters speak in the books, and not try to make them little more than a bunch of 20th century stereotypes. The Trek novel universe would be better for it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|