Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An Enjoyable (if shallow) Pageturner, May 28, 2002
Whether you like this book will depend on large part how willing you are the accept its basic premise: that a slightly geeky 20-something Londoner would keep a drunken bet (his passport, Euro Star pass, and honeymoon tickets vs. a collectible set of train tickets) that he could travel the entire London tube system in a day, that day being the one before he gets married. If you're willing to roll with that premise, then you're probably willing to overlook the shallowness of the characters and the herky-jerky flow of the book. Some may find the protagonist Andy a bit hard to like, since he's largely in a mess of his own making, however he's got just that right balance of geek and everyman about him to keep you rooting for him. For reasons that are never explained, a homeless man of remarkable stamina, coherency and wisdom decides to tag along for the fun, which gives Andy someone to relate the story of his relationship to and someone to save the day from time to time. Andy's friend Rolf, with whom he made the bet, is at least given some motivation for his nefarious actions-although he also comes across as a one-dimensional supergeekvillan. The story is probably best appreciated by those who've had wide contact with the London tube, although you could pretty much do the same story in New York (although it would take more like a weekend). In fact, don't be surprised if the movie takes this route (and there will be a movie, rarely have I come across a book that translates so directly to screen as this). Of course, one expects complications and wacky hijinks to ensue, and they do, but somehow aren't as wacky as one expects. And then there's a whole semi-conspiracy subplot which peters out disappointingly. In any event, like many other young male novels of recent years (High Fidelity comes to mind), the book attempts to probe the idea of the adult boy becoming an adult man and leaving behind childish things (or at least keeping them in their proper place). However, it never really lives up to its potential there either. In the end, what one has is a book that never quite lives up to its potential, but is nonetheless an enjoyable pageturner. There are plenty of other books available on the London tube, including Geoff Ryman's interesting hypertext novel, "253," Simon James' collection of photos "Mind the Gap," Tobias Hill's thriller "Underground," Barbara Vine's mystery "King Solomon's Carpet," and Christopher Ross' book about working on the tube, "Tunnel Visions."
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Went a little long, but altogether enjoyable...(3 1/2 stars), December 22, 2004
This almost 400 page book takes the time of an entire day starting at 5:00 in the morning. Andy leaves his flat early while his fiance Rachel quietly sleeps. He's supposed to leave on the Eurostar train with Rachel, at midnight, but he happened to make a bet with his "friend you love to hate" Rolf, who is a "tube enthusiast," like himself.
So, the bet goes like this. Rolf thinks that Andy cannot travel around the ENTIRE tube in a single day. Andy thinks that he can. He is supposed to go around and take pictures of all of the signs, pick up envelopes that are taped to non-moving trains and behind soda machines, and finish before the Eurostar is supposed to leave. He is supposed to receive the last envelope from Rolf, which contains his tickets. Will he make it?
Knowing the unpredictability of the London underground, this made for an original plot. There can be delays, accidents, people throwing themselves on the tracks. He can't take any overground transportation, it has to be the tube. If Rachel finds out about this bet, where he basically threw his marriage in the pot, would she still marry him? She tries to ignore his obsession with the underground, but this is ridiculous.
All in all, it was fun to read about. It was very detailed and made me wonder if the author walked through his book, tracking down small details as he went. For a while, I was starting to wonder if it would become boring, following Andy through his travels all alone, but he met Brian, a homeless man who jumped on his coattails. Andy is annoyed with him at first, but the longer they are around each other, they start to form an unlikely friendship. Brian makes the story a little more readable.
I didn't give it more stars because even though it was interesting, it wasn't engrossing, and I picked up and put down the book several times before I finished it. Maybe it was the length of the novel. Maybe, even though I'm obsessed with London and it's contents, that a book about traveling on the underground doesn't have enough drama for me. But, it was a nice ride, all the same.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
an evening's worth of entertainment, December 27, 2001
This book drew me in immediately. The first person narration by Andy is delighful. He tells his story as though he were speaking directly to me, the reader. I found this particularly engaging. This technique helps the story immensely because we, as readers, are able to sympathize with Andy. His obsessive tendencies, delusional optimism, and extreme paranoia don't seem that freakish when viewed through his eyes. Andy just seems like a good guy. I would recommend this book to anyone who has ever gotten carried away, anyone who tends to be a little obsessive, or anyone who likes a good action filled book. The story moves quickly and so do the pages. Read this book for fun. The first few chapters had me laughing out loud.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|