|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable light fantasy fare for the 9-12 age group, September 15, 2002
In a time of great need, a hero will rise above his humble origins to lead his people out of oppression...Well, in this case, the hero's name is Rollo, and he's a troll. And if you think the plot sounds familiar, it is. However, it's not a bad reincarnation of this sort of story, particularly if something like a mix between Star Wars and Redwall (with trolls and ogres instead of mice and moles) appeals to you. Actually, what I was most reminded of while reading The Troll King were those old adventure/fantasy computer games-- colorful, entertaining, quick paced, and even sort of inclusive of those inventories in which every item becomes necessary at some point in the game. And also, like those games, rather shallow. Characters are part of the problem. Rollo is young, strong, handsome (for a troll, anyway), clever, and also honest and firmly on the side of Good. For exactly those reasons, I never found him to be an interestingly three dimensional character. And likewise with the other characters, though the evil people aren't as badly stereotyped and flat as they could have been. There are also instances in which the author makes it painfully clear to what age group he is writing, with really unnecessary inclusions such as: "Her gutteral voice sang a sweet lullaby about picking leeches off her thigh to make a pie." Eeeeew! There are also the ghouls, magically animated corpses, who are described in some detail. And yet, exactly the things I might have gotten a kick out of when I was nine. And though there are a few amusing sides about trolls coming 'out from under the bridge,' The Troll King isn't really suitable for an adult audience, as are really good children's and YA books. Nonetheless, there are much worse ways to spend an hour, and I think that it's very well suited to its target audience-- the younger Harry Potter fans. It has some basic lessons about loyalty and prejudice without ever getting annoyingly preachy, and is very readable. The end leaves the door wide open for a sequel, and as it promises to deal with the Bonny Woods, by far the most interesting and least explored area of Vornholt's fantasy world, I just might read it. Ailanna
|