Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The entire combat history of the U.S. Army from the American Revolution to modern times, making for an outstanding survey., February 8, 2007
A number of books chart U.S. Army members, achievements, and battles; but few offer the general public a fine visual overview as does Army: An Illustrated History, suitable for public library lending. Dramatic paintings, action photos and battle maps survey the army's changes, success, failures, and growth around the world, juxtaposing history and biography with technological insights on weaponry and battlefield strategies. Historian Chester Hearn covers the entire combat history of the U.S. Army from the American Revolution to modern times, making for an outstanding survey.
Diane C. Donovan
California Bookwatch
|
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not bad for what it is (until Iraq, anyway), July 5, 2009
This is a not-bad anecdotal history of the U.S. Army (not armies in general) by a non-academic military history buff. He begins at the beginning, with the colonial militia in New England exterminating the Narragansett Indians, and by the end of Chapter 2 he has reached the beginning of the 20th Century. This hectic pace slows in the following seven chapters, which cover the World Wars, Korea, Vietnam, and Iraq. The author generally takes a rah-rah approach to his subject, which is to be expected these days, but he does seem to manage a balanced narrative most of time, pointing out (for instance) that McKinley was decidedly unenthusiastic about war with Spain and that Theodore Roosevelt's Medal of Honor for San Juan Hill was purely political. Nor is he an apologist for U.S. expansionism in the Pacific and Latin America. The chapter on Pershing and the AEF seems a bit disjointed, but the two chapters on World War II (one each for Europe and the Pacific) is a good survey. I approached the Vietnam chapter somewhat reluctantly since that's my generation's war, but Hearn manages not to call names and recognizes the key role played by reluctant and resentful draftees in the U.S. defeat. (You can't force soldiers to accept the necessity of a given war if they don't really believe it.) It's also refreshing to read an unblinkered account of figures like Patton, MacArthur, and Audie Murphy. He often includes appreciation of military leaders like Stilwell and Buckner, too, who are less well-known today. Coverage of women and blacks in the army, on the other hand, is a bit thin, but it's there. As he enters the Reagan era, however, Hearn begins to leave objectivity behind; the invasion of Grenada is, for him, principally an opportunity to experiment with new military doctrine. He also falls into the common conservative calumny of blaming all military failures on the media and/or politicians -- forgetting that, in a democracy, the military command structure is not going to be allowed to run everything its own way without civilian control. By the time of the first Gulf War, he's in full cheerleader mode and Bush's invasion of Iraq is not only justified but glorious. The final chapter, "Into the Future," is positively poetic in its promises of the "Army of One" and its unbeatable new weapons systems, . . . which, one suspects, will be just as vulnerable to cheap IEDs. Of course, this is first and foremost an *illustrated* history, and while there are a few very well-known photos (Eisenhower delivering a pep talk to the 101st just before the Normandy landings), most are probably new to most readers. Not a bad book for what it is, as long as you read the last third of the volume with your eyes open.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
GREAT for the Military History Buff, January 19, 2009
My son loves these books. They are well written with great pictures. Definitely for the Military history buff
|
|
|
|