|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Poorly organized by anyones standards. Missing Data, November 26, 2002
By A Customer
This title would seem like a good buy on the surface and its pretty [inexpensive]. Don't allow yourself to think it would be worthwhile even as a throw-away reference... Don't be fooled.This book suffers from being out of date early in its life... But that can't be a major hit against it. I say this because its a guide to a MMORPG - change is their bread-n-butter so no hard-copy reference will remain relevant for long. The major hit against this book is that its imcomplete and poorly organized. It does a decent job on the surface but lacks key information - for instance, it includes an extensive MOB list but leaves out loot lists for them (it would be nice to at least list special loot items - even if all loot items were not included) and fails to list where these MOBs can be found. Additionally, not all vendor available items are listed and those that are listed are sometimes listed without a location where they can be purchased. Drop only items (items only gotten through killing a MOB) are listed as drop-only - no reference to which mob drops them. LAZY! More than 50% of listed items are listed with missing stats, missing purchase locations or are just plain incorrect - in some cases by orders of magnitude. Engines in the game use Thrust and Warp numbers. Warp is in the thousands and thrust in the hundreds. The book lists warp for engines in terms of warp level - something which defies translation into warp speed making the guide combersome as a reference. Weapons are organized in a haphazard way making it difficult to compare similar items of the same class and level. No additional calculated statistics (damage/second, damage/energy) are provided making it even more difficult to make comparisons. Devices aren't even listed - no where! Devices are a large part of the game (Engines, Shields, Weapons, DEVICES). Its icomprehensible that they were omitted from this "official guide". As a reference guide, this is no great guide. As a strategy guide its even worse leaving out key elements of the game and not describing those things that even in beta where passed by word of mouth amongst the players: 1) never take your Cygni engine - which is irreplacable - out on combat missions (items over level 3 can be permanently damaged when your hull takes significant damage or you are disabled); 2) analyse all items at your current build item level before increasing your skill level to maximize experience points eanred, etc etc... - this is especially true for analyzing components which rarely fail and can provide good explore XP; 3) Never use exploration experience gained by visiting unexplored navigation pts to pay off experience debt from being killed. Explore experience is the hardest to get in the game for all races. Its best to go on a killing spree - MOBs are always available; etc etc Terrible! Terrible! Terrible! Don't buy it. That's my advice. If I could, I'd have given it negative 5 stars. I fully believe that should the book be updated, the new edtion should be sent to all current owners by way of compensation and the book should include a CDROM containing all data collected from the game in a format which is completely accessible. At the very least, a website should have been created in concert with the book which contains the data from the game and is kept up to date and can continue as a reference. Halek L100 Terran Enforcer
|
