From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 3-This breezy update of Wojciechowski's 1992 title (Crown) features a more direct narrative voice as well as a few new illustrations. There's a lot more dialogue, especially between narrator Ben and his older brother Michael, and the text appears to be hand printed, allowing certain words and phrases to be emphasized (via slightly larger and darker letters) just as they might be in conversation. The story remains the same, however, with Ben cataloging the inventive costumes created by his parents and, finally declaring his independence by designing his own (much simpler) one. The illustrations are also very close to the originals, though it appears that some pictures and the overall page size are slightly larger. This creates a less text-heavy look, making the new version more inviting and accessible. The added pictures fit seamlessly into the story, expanding the humor and adding to the fun. Even libraries that own the previous edition will want to consider purchasing a few new copies of this charming Halloween treat.
Lisa Dennis, The Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, PACopyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
Ages 4^-7. First published in 1992, this amusing picture book concerns a boy whose Halloween costumes, all cheerfully made by Mom and Dad, have led to holiday after holiday of embarrassment and physical discomfort. Now seven years old, the young narrator takes matters into his own hands and fashions a costume that suits him better. Apart from some changes in typography and in the size, positioning, and backgrounds of illustrations, the book's most noticeable difference is the text, now tightened and rewritten to bring out the humor. A fresh version of a holiday read-aloud treat.
Carolyn Phelan
See all Editorial Reviews