|
38 of 39 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best "non-bible like" php book, October 18, 2001
It took me only about 15 minutes to size this book up and it's a winner. It's concise, complete, and extremely well organized. It's a heck of a good reference when you're programming and just can't remember something. And unlike most of the programming books I've used, it's large titles (every two pages are a "module" discussing an important concept) make it EASY to find exactly what you're looking for.IT'S UNIQUE, AND IT'S ACTUALLY INTELLIGENTLY WRITTEN ------------------------------------------------------------ What's unique about this book is that the information is presents is very easily digestable. I own 4 php books including this one, and none of them are as useful to me on a day to day basis, because finding information in them is so much work--I usually just end up looking on google. Most of the books I own (and I do own quite a few), well, they.... um.... suck. Especially after you realized they're index is not good for looking things up or they're written like the hobbit (actually, we have a theory about that... you see... how do hobbits make money after all...). Additionally, the format seems to appeal to different kinds of learners. I am more brainy in the way that I learn, but my more corporeal "hands-on" programmer friend (who learns by doing) took one look at this thing and insisted I order him a copy (which is the reason I'm writing reviews, don't you know ;-). I think the format will appeal to a wide variety of learners. WHAT'S REALLY REALLY GOOD ------------------------------------------------------------ * Awesome format * Complete index * easy to find information * clear writing * well laid out information * introductions to more advanced material (like how to set up a mysql database) * the entire book is on PDF on the CD, which is SO COMPLETELY AWESOME IT SOLD THE BOOK (publisher if you read this, it's the reason I bought a copy of your book -- keep it up). No more wishing you had a copy of the book with you at work when you need it -- now you don't have to own 2 copies to have a decent reference!!! * It's CHEAP. I'm buying a number of this series because it's almost like two for one on Amazon. * lots of pictures and screen shots (that make sense for once!) * an example on the same page as almost every category * it's the same format most folks learn in -- do and then see what happens, then do this and see what happens, etc... WHAT'S NOT GOOD, OR COULD BE IMPROVED ------------------------------------------------------------ * Could use a little more in depth information * Could use a keyed index (in other words, put the page number of the page the stuff you're talking about is referenced in the reference section -- a minor, but useful, tune up) * Index of functions, while useful, it pretty slim on explination * Missing more comprehensive examples -- how do you put it all together kind of material. Kind of a mixed blessing. * It has a few typos. And as you know BOOKS are not supposed to be like web pages. * I'll bet you one of the examples is broken somehow. All computer books have a broken example in them. It's like, a cyber-rule. Really. So go find it. Go on. Email me and I'll put it in the review (I couldn't find anything that looks obviously messed up straight off). * A map of the php world would rock. I love books that give me nice big fold-out "reminescent of National Geographic" maps of programming languages. <sniff> * This book could be improved if it was packaged with $100 dollars of cold hard cash. That's a joke. WHAT I REALLY THINK (REALLY!) ------------------------------------------------------------ In short, this book won't help you write better programs or give you a really good framework for understanding and developing applications (and don't be fooled, most books that claim to suck continuiously for 500 pages before boring you into submission). It will get you productive in php and teach you what you need to know. And the pdf version of the book on cd makes this the benchmark computer book format (it's like it's, NOOO!!! It's from the future!!! Oh my god, another publisher realized that releasing computer books in pdf won't hurt sales, and in fact encourages users to buy more of their books! <nod o'reilly> THE BOTTOM LINE ------------------------------------------------------------ If you're a beginner/intermediate, or even just want something to use as a reference or occasionally brush up, this should be in your library.
|