Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
James Bond meets Heinlein Stereotypical Potboiler, December 7, 2005
I came to this from John Maddox Roberts' sophisticated SPQR series, set in ancient Rome, and was disappointed by the drop in quality. I thought perhaps the two writers just needed more time to get used to one another -- but this is their fourth book together, though the first with these characters.
The first error was surely not the fault of the authors, whom one assumes were mortified. On page 11, the protagonist goes on about how he prefers reporters with scientific backgrounds, who won't make mistakes that are then attributed to him. The very next paragraph identifies an aircraft as a "Cesna" rather than a "Cessna." The simple typo wouldn't be so blush-worthy were it not juxtaposed with the protagonist's barbed remarks about technical accuracy.
Overall, I liked the science and particularly enjoyed the global socio-economic aspects of the plot, but was disappointed by three things in its execution:
===A. the level of cliché -- the beautiful-but-covertly-brainy reporter with martial arts skills (once they made this character Asian, the chop-socky was inevitable), the bravura capitalism (there's the Heinlein for you), the effete Frenchman, the freakish but omnipotent hacker recluse, the wicked Eastern Bloc assassin, the stoic Native American bodyguard, the good-old-boy Texan who gotta-gonna solve the world's oil problem. The authors waited until page 229 before making the inevitable "Cowboy & Indian" remark, bless them, and they did take a few baby steps away from the stereotypes, but baby steps are not enough when great strides are called for.
===B. it REEKED of screenplay, so why bother with the book at all? And it would be quite a successful movie, say with Bruce Willis and Lucy Liu, so why waste time in New York when they could have taken the outline directly to Hollywood?
===C. the unsubtle foreshadowing of what would come next in the series -- but there's been no "next" yet, though five years have passed, so perhaps there will be no series, after all.
If you like James Bond, if you like the older Heinlein novels, if you're secretly hot for Ayn Rand, you'll like this very much. If they'd had the guts to scramble their stereotypes a little -- how about making the love interest a she-geek hermit who is NOT beautiful? Or try out an assassin made bitter by her failure to advance in the U.S. military, or a Frenchman who's not a pantywaist, and let the Native American be the wealthy scientist-entrepreneur instead of Tonto -- etc., etc. -- I might have liked it very much, too.
|
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mediocre Science Fiction, September 24, 2002
In this novel, as in reality, oil is becoming scarce, so this gives incentive to an international race to put a solar energy satellite into geostationary orbit to beam energy down to earth. This may actually happen someday, but mabe not, if it does it is decades off, at least. I found the character development to be sketchy at best, with the plot amateurish at times. The ending was abrupt, with the whole novel being a bit too brief. It was not a page turner for me, however I have read worse science fiction than this. According to the cover on this book one of the authors, Eric Kotani, is a pseudonym for a world-class astrophysicist, so there is some actual science included here so not all is lost, it is informative to some extent, but for me it just did'nt have the 'fire' other science fiction I have read did.
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good start for a series! More, please!, October 3, 2000
I was first drawn to "Legacy" because of the premise of the solar power farming using satellites, a concept that inspired me 20 years ago to give up a dead end life style and go back to school. It was a senior project done by the Aerospace school at the University of Michigan named "Project Rodan", I believe.The character development is wonderful with believable business and government senarios. The wheeling and dealing at the highest level reminds me of the Heinlein novels where money was secondary and vision and persistance win out over deceit and treachary. My only complaint is that there seem to be a few chapters missing. These team of characters are too good to leave hanging out there... especially when a "first contact" may be eminent.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|