From School Library Journal
Grade 4–7—Jule's parents have been missing for 10 years and, most recently, the girl's aunt has disappeared. Then Jule finds herself left behind after the MegaMall closes for the day. She is absorbed into one of the competing tribes of children who live there, scavenging for their subsistence needs. Jule soon learns that virtually all of their parents have disappeared. As the plot unfolds, readers are introduced to the mastermind of the mall. A man whose face was so disfigured by his peers as a child that he keeps it hidden, he has pledged revenge on all children. This futuristic book has a great premise, but fails in its execution. The characters are two-dimensional, with the villain drawn as almost a cartoon caricature. The repetition of "Ohhh, nooooooo," although intended to reveal the shallow, controlled thoughts of adults in custody, instead comes off as tedious and uninspired. The rotation of character perspectives through the different chapters is difficult to follow. This book cannot hold a candle to Jeanne DuPrau's "Books of Ember" (Random) or Anthony Horowitz's "The Gatekeepers" series (Scholastic).—
Leah Krippner, Harlem High School, Machesney Park, IL Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Reed, an Alex Award winner for Thinner than Thou (2006), now comes with her first novel for young readers. Various groups of kids who have been abandoned by their parents live on the fringes of the gigantic Megamall, owned by the mysterious billionaire Amos Zozz. What starts out as a turf war between two such gangs escalates into much more, as the kids uncover what might have really happened to their parents—and what the clearly insane Zozz has in store for them. The kids in this thriller have some solid dimension, but the adults almost none. (Zozz has exactly two character traits: an insatiable lust for power and an insatiable hatred for children, making him an ideal villain). The condemnation of greedy corporations might not quite hit its mark, and by the end, the premise becomes too preposterous to take seriously, but readers will get caught up by the fast pace and plucky group of kids sticking it to the Man. The ending satisfies and also leaves things ripe for a sequel. Grades 4-7. --Ian Chipman
See all Editorial Reviews