|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Lots of information, but very badly presented and edited, June 12, 2003
This book tries to cover a tremendous amount of territory: * The history of document markup and XML. * XML concepts and syntax. * Document analysis and DTD and schema design. * CSS * XSL/XSLT * An array of development tools * A range of XML application servers * IE channels * RDF, P3P, WDDX, MathML, SMIL * Case studies from D&B, DellThat's an impressive and ambitious list. Unfortunately, the authors are over reaching and have prepared a book that looks like it was rushed to market. It is full of typos, grammar mistakes and nonsensical examples. It is almost incoherent in some places. The coverage from chapter to chapter is extremely uneven: Chapter 22 provides 13 pages of coverage on XML and Java. If it only took 13 pages to teach it to you, you probably wouldn't need the book to learn it. Even as a dedicated reader with eight years' experience in publishing and content management, I found these shortcomings extremely frustrating and confusing. If you need a survey book that covers a lot of stuff about XML without really trying to teach you the language and how to work with it, this book might be okay. For example, a business manager who has heard about XML or is contributing to the decision to use the technology might get some mileage out of the Dell or D&B case study. A curious home user just trying to get their feet wet might also appreciate the book not giving too much technical detail. But if you're in technology or really need to learn how to use XML, Mastering XML is not a good choice. Its shallow coverage of the language's fundamentals and the hardcore technology for using it will disappoint. (...)
|