From School Library Journal
Grade 4-6. Twelve-year-old Ethan Winfield thinks life is unfair. His older brother is a top student and eighth-grade basketball star at their Colorado middle school, while he prefers low-level reading books and has little aptitude for sports. When his best friend, Julius, suggests they form a club called Losers, Inc., Ethan is ready for membership, making a game of the quest for super-loser status. However, with the appearance of Ms. Gunderson, a beautiful student teacher who will help the sixth-graders prepare quality science-fair projects, Ethan comes to realize that he has no desire to do badly. In fact, his crush unleashes an unfamiliar determination to succeed that both confuses and energizes him, putting a strain on his friendship with Julius. As Ethan begins on an original and hopefully prize-winning project, he is pestered by a classmate, Lizzie Archer, who sends him love poems. He takes part in a scam to trick her into applying to a bogus poetry contest of which she will be the sole winner, but later rues his dishonesty and cruelty as he strives to be worthy of his idol, Ms. Gunderson. Pacing and readability are strengths in this third-person tale with a comfortable mix of adolescent angst and decency. The characters are believable, and even the eccentric and intellectual Lizzie, whose unpopularity overshadows her human vulnerabilities, is portrayed sympathetically. An appealing mix of classroom scenes, basketball action, and tentative steps toward maturity.?Susan W. Hunter, Riverside Middle School, Springfield, VT
Copyright 1997 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
From Booklist
Gr. 5^-7. Life is unfair to middle-grader Ethan Winfield and his best friend, Julius, so they form a losers' club. Then Ethan gets a crush on the new student teacher, and suddenly losing is no longer attractive. He wants to impress her. He reads Dickens for his book report (instead of the shortest book on the shelf). He wants to do the best science project (and without his bumbling pal). Maybe Ethan could do as well as his perfect older brother: is that a betrayal of his friend? Meanwhile, the class nerd gets a crush on Ethan, and, to his shame, he joins the bullies in a mean trick to humiliate her. As she did with the girls' scene in
Dinah Forever (1995), Mills writes here with touching comedy about a boy's muddle at home and at school. The dinner table scenes are a delight: there are those who talk and those who don't. The teacher is too perfect--as beautiful as Rapunzel and also wise and gentle--but many kids will recognize the power of a crush to change the way you see the world. Most moving is the friendship-disloyalty drama. Who's the loser?
Hazel Rochman
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
See all Editorial Reviews