Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
31 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Did you like Sword and Fist?, April 30, 2001
If you liked Sword and Fist, and/or you are interested in playing a Cleric or Paladin character, this is a good book for you. It has alot of new spells, new armors, new prestige classes (some of which are very cool) and of course, new FEATS. So really, anyone could use it, no matter what character class you play. On the other hand, if you are looking for alot of "source" matierial, or ideas on how to play these classes, then this book will disappoint you. It is very much a RULES book, expanding the mechanics of the game but not the culture of the game. The exception to this is a nicely written section on various kinds of temples and what one could expect to find in them, but I found this information to be a bit obvious. The best reason to buy the book is for the new spells and feats. If you aren't interested or cant keep up with the ones alreay out there, you will do well to save your money.
|
|
|
35 of 39 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Generally Mediocre, May 29, 2001
"Defenders of the Faith: A Guidebook to Clerics and Paladins" was decidedly mediocre for some reason. It contains useful information for playing a cleric or paladin in third edition, but for some reason it just didn't seem as useful as "Sword and Fist". Some of the nicer ideas included the different type of paladin's mounts (or cohorts), new (but slightly repetitive) feats, prestige domains, and new spells. The different suggestions for playing clerics and paladins were generally interesting and helpful, but nothing really new. Not quite as good are the prestige classes. It seemed many of them were almost repetitive or boring. Unlike "Sword and Fist", none of them made me want to try to build a character so that eventually I could use the prestige class. A few of the magic items seemed to be unrelated to the cleric or paladin class, in general. In fact, that's part of the problem with the book. It feels like the book was cobbled together at the last minute so that there would be a book for clerics and paladins. Unlike "Sword and Fists" brilliant little additions, there's nothing in "Defenders of the Faith" that really makes it really interesting. It feels more like a second edition "Player's Handbook to Clerics" for third edition and that is not a compliment. I would say that if you're like me and you like to own all the third edition books, feel free to pick it up. It'll probably be useful in the long run for DMs to use for NPCs. Or if you like clerics or paladins best out of all the classes, again, give it a go and buy it. Otherwise, there really is no need to pick up this book.
|
|
|
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Much Better than S&F, May 15, 2001
Which, of course, doesn't tell us much about this, since S&F really wasn't that good.This is, as you may've guessed, the D&D3 splatbook for clerics and paladins. In it, you'll find a collection of roleplaying and character advice, new equipment, prestige classes, and spells. There are also sample temples based on alignment, and a few other organizations. What's good? Well, for starters, the material is more substantive. There's more here on almost every subject, leading to a lack of intentional filler material. The prestige classes are decent, and I liked the advice on playing a paladin. Having non-standard mounts is also a nice touch. What's bad? Not so much as S&F. Actually, very little specifically bad. It seemed a tad dense to me, and a lot of the new abilities are rather...munchkin-capable. (A member of my party uses one ability, I forget the name, that has him spend a turning attempt and get a massive attack and damage bonus...and his charisma is rather high) Also, the appendix with monster religions is disappointing; while a nice thing to get you started, I wonder why each humanoid race has only one deity. Check out the old AD&D2 Monster Mythology, or for demihumans, the FR supp. Demihuman Deities. All in all, not bad. I wasn't disappointed, but wasn't that thrilled.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|