|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Two good story tellers don't give us their usual product, April 24, 2000
Weiss and Hickman have created a prodigious body of work based on the mythical world of Krynn. Regrettably, this particular anthology of short stories is inconsistent, in both tone and quality, with their usually fine craftsmanship. As a whole, the collection suffers from a lack of focus, though there are bright spots.'Legacy' is generally well written and focused, yet leaves a great deal unanswered insofar as what was illusion and what was "real" in Palin's test. The young dark Paladin is a plausible product of Kitiara's lifestyle, and a possible, though improbable, outcome of her previously described journey North with Sturm. In a glaring story telling omission, tension is absent and obstacles trivially overcome when a party tries to infiltrate both the Dark Paladin's fortress and the High Clerist's Tower. And the weight of a blue dragon's passengers is utterly ignored. 'Raistlin's Daughter' is well put together. The Search for the Greygem, which includes the sons of Caramon, is silly and blatantly devoid of the detail most Weiss/Hickman tales receive. A ludicrous "PC" theme is added which not only detracts from the lame plot, but utterly ignores the adaptability of people. This story reads like a shoddily produced "Monty Hall" D & D module: hope it was never run at a tournament. A comment on a structural weakness Weiss and Hickman have built into the world of Krynn, steel currency notwithstanding. They can never portray Kender, Gnomes, or Gully Dwarves with any sobriety, and often portray "normal" Dwarves as silly. This is inconsistent with the gravity with which humans and elves are generally portrayed, and leads to an enormously unbalanced world view. It is the fundamental weakness of the Krynn fantasy world, one which they will probably never change. Considering the well designed world presented in the Rose of the Prophet Trilogy, and the absence of sillines in the Dark Sword Chronicles, they know how to do it, they just choose to keep the Kender and Gnomes on the Jar Jar Binks level of character depth: which is a pity. In the Graygem quest, combining this flaw with three characters who are elsewhere treated with some realism, and who represent the continuation of a line of heroes, seems like self-sacrelige on the authors' part. For the non-Krynn veteran, avoid this book, it is far below Weiss and Hickman's normal standard. For Krynn fans, it is worth a look, but best checked out of a library.
|