Consumers in the Country: Technology and Social Change in Rural America (Revisiting Rural America) (Hardcover)

by Ronald R. Kline (Author) "The telephone was the first of our four allegedly urbanizing technologies to be adopted in rural America..." (more)
Key Phrases: overworked farm woman, urbanizing technologies, electrical modernity, New York, World War, New Deal (more...)

Editorial Reviews

Review
"His social historical-technological approach makes any historical study of technology ultimately much more valuable."—Tyler O. Walters, Journal of Illinois History -- Tyler O. Walters, Journal of Illinois History

"Kline's work is a welcome addition to this body of scholarship."—Pamela Riney-Kehrberg, Kansas History -- —Pamela Riney-Kehrberg, Kansas History

"This extremely thorough presentation presents a clear picture of how industries changed, and were changed by, farm families."—Choice -- Choice --This text refers to the Paperback edition.

Review

"Kline's work is strong in a number of areas... The study is a well written and well researched compilation... and should be standard reading for those interested in the transformation of rural America in the twentieth century." -- Allen Shepherd, Nebraska History

"Kline fills a real gap in our understanding of the ways rural Americans incorporated technology into their daily lives." -- Melissa Walker, Journal of American History

"His social historical-technological approach makes any historical study of technology ultimately much more valuable." -- Tyler O. Walters, Journal of Illinois History

"Kline's work is a welcome addition to this body of scholarship." -- Pamela Riney-Kehrberg, Kansas History

"Consumers in the Country provides an important and very welcome venture into both the history of consumption patterns -- an underdeveloped subject in our field -- and nonurban people." -- Deborah Fitzgerald, Technology and Culture

"Careful, meticulously researched, and well written." -- David Blanke, Annals of Iowa

"This extremely thorough presentation presents a clear picture of how industries changed, and were changed by, farm families." -- Choice

"Consumers in the Country makes important contributions to scholarship in the history and theory of technology and the social history of rural life." -- Mark Finlay, History: Reviews of New Books

"Well-researched, entertaining, and generally convincing." -- Brian Q. Cannon, Western Historical Quarterly

"Kline does a fine job in describing the ways in which rural people made new technologies part of their lives, noting regional, class, and gender implications. His writing is clear, thoughtful, intelligent, and often highly amusing." -- Jeanette Keith, Journal of Appalachian Studies

"Kline's presentation of farmers as historical actors who controlled acceptance of technology on their own terms is valuable and should inform future studies of agricultural communities." -- Barbara Handy-Marchello, Great Plains Research

"Kline displays a confident grasp of technology. He really understands how things work and he has the ability to explain this to readers. This is a rare and valuable quality. He also has an exemplary understanding of the social dimension of technology, throwing new light on the relationship between farm people and modernizers." -- David B. Danbom, North Dakota State University

"A welcome addition." -- Pamela Riney-Kehrberg, Kansas History

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 384 pages
• Publisher: The Johns Hopkins University Press; Revised edition (April 6, 2000)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0801862485
• ISBN-13: 978-0801862489
• Product Dimensions: 9.4 x 6.3 x 1.2 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.6 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 4.0 out of 5 stars See all reviews (1 customer review)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #2,394,716 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars Meticulous research, April 11, 2004

By	Erika Mitchell (E. Calais, VT USA) - See all my reviews (TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)

This book is an in-depth exploration into the social forces behind the adoption of 4 technologies into rural American households in the early Twentieth century: the telephone, the automobile, the radio, and electricity. The book also describes some of the social changes that came about as a result of the adoption of these technologies.

The book is divided into three section. The first section looks at each of the technologies in turn. The second deals with rural electrification, and the third sums up the material. Also included are appendices, with much statistical data about the technologies, endnotes, an annotated bibliography, and an index.

Personally, I found the first section most interesting. It was fascinating to read about attitudes towards these technologies before they came to be seen as necessities. Indeed, as Kline describes, rural families were doing just fine without them, and often resisted the technologies when they were first introduced. But the social possibilities brought by the telephone and radio did provide a welcome social outlet, especially for women. Between listening in on party lines (which Kline is careful to point out was done by both genders), and listening to music and talk shows on the radio, women found that the hours spent in housework seemed to go by faster, even if the number of housework hours weren't necessarily shortened by technology as predicted by home economists of the times. Indeed, some of Kline's most interesting points were about economists and home economists of the early Twentieth century. One reason why policy makers thought it was so important for farm families to modernize and take up the new technologies was that they wanted to stem the flow of people leaving farms to work in the cities. Looking back from our perspective today, it's much more clear that the reason people were leaving the farms was to head for the greater economic opportunity of the city, not to improve social conditions. As farm technology improved and farmers became more efficient, each increment of farm production would have become less valuable- -if the government really wanted to keep people on the farms, they should have restricted farmers from acquiring technology instead of encouraging it. Kline describes how farmers came up with their own creative uses of technology, based on their real needs, rather than on what the experts thought they needed. They hooked up machinery including clothes washers to the axels of their cars instead of using the gas engines that had been built for these purposes, they used automobiles to plow their fields before diesel tractors were developed, and they used telephones to broadcast home concerts for the enjoyment of all their neighbors.

I found the minute detail of the second section dealing with the political history of the Rural Electrification Administration (REA) to be a bit overwhelming. Kline did some extensive research to complete this section, and it is all very well documented, but general readers might have found a more broad overview a little more palatable. The discussion of how the REA had to find ways to get farmers to increase their electric usage was particularly illuminating. As Kline describes the situation, once farmers were connected to a central power station, all they wanted to do was to run a light bulb or two and maybe a radio. But such light usage would not allow the electrical co-op to pay off its loans for stringing the lines, so the REA promoted all sorts of high energy consumption appliances, from electric ranges and hot water heaters to milking machines. It took some 20 to 40 years to get farmers to start consuming enough electricity to make their connections to the grid worthwhile to the co- ops. So how much longer will it take to convince regular consumers as well as farmers to reduce their consumption of electricity? Something tells me once habits have become ingrained into the culture, it's easier to build demand than to decrease it.