The Double-Edged Helix: Social Implications of Genetics in a Diverse Society (Hardcover)

~ Joseph S. Alper (Author), Catherine Ard (Editor), Adrienne Asch (Editor), Peter Conrad (Editor), Lisa N. Geller (Editor), Jon Beckwith (Author) "In February 2001, two competing research groups announced the near-completion of the primary goal of the Human Genome Project: the DNA sequence of the entire..." (more)
Key Phrases: term gay gene, genetic testing technologies, genetic discrimination, New York, United States, African Americans (more...)

Editorial Reviews

From The New England Journal of Medicine

The Double-Edged Helix takes a cautious look at the effects of genetic discoveries on society. It warns that neither society nor genetics is governed by simple cause-and-effect mechanisms and that this complexity creates potential for both benefit and harm. The reader is reminded that social inequality has been justified, maintained, and promoted by ugly misapplications of science. Most of the 20 contributors have specialties outside of genetics, and none are prominent in the field of human genetics. This might account for the fact that the 13 chapters draw only superficially on the literature in human genetics. It might also explain the heavy reliance on a few examples. Several chapters repudiate Dean Hamer's study of homosexuality. Daniel Kevles's history of eugenics (In the Name of Eugenics. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1985) is praised in several chapters. Curiously, the authors neglect to inform their readers that Kevles found that many geneticists abandoned eugenics as it became incompatible with their science. Reductionism and deterministic biologic theories are among the book's targets, but it does not provide a good framework for understanding complex interactions. This task is not beyond the scope of a book for nonspecialists. The popular writings of J.B.S. Haldane from the early 20th century manage it with clarity and wit. The Double-Edged Helix correctly identifies complex interactions as a likely reason that contributions of specific genes underlying schizophrenia have yet to be confirmed. It is disappointing that the book overlooks the parallel failure to identify manipulable environmental determinants of schizophrenia and the harm that has been caused by spurious environmental explanations such as schizophrenigenic mothers. The treatment of genetic diversity, race, and ethnic background ignores decades of literature in the biologic and social sciences in failing to provide rigorous definitions of race and even racism. The authors argue that genetic diversity should not be studied, because the value of such studies is limited relative to the risk of their misuse by racists. However, the failure to recognize genetic differences also has consequences -- for example, the boondoggle caused by forcing milk products on regions of the world with a high incidence of lactose intolerance. Geneticists studying differences among populations are urged to become more active in countering racist claims. This is good advice for everybody to follow. A major strength of this book is its recognition that our society encompasses persons and groups with diverse interests. These interests do not always run in parallel, and a benefit for one sector may be a drawback for another. Genetic testing for Tay-Sachs disease has been helpful for Ashkenazi Jews, whereas a similar program of genetic testing for sickle cell anemia in black Americans was disastrous. A serious disconnection between the goals of genetic researchers and the challenges faced by those with genetic disorders is demonstrated in the chapter on advocacy groups. The issues raised by this book are valid, and all scientists should be aware of them. I often found myself nodding in agreement while reading The Double-Edged Helix, but I became dissatisfied as I gave the topics more thought. Still, the book presents an outsider's view that has a funny effect somewhat like that of seeing your reflection in a department-store window: it is fuzzy and inaccurate, but it captures some truths that you would rather not see. Jeffrey C. Long, Ph.D.
Copyright © 2003 Massachusetts Medical Society. All rights reserved. The New England Journal of Medicine is a registered trademark of the MMS.

Review

"Bringing the concerns of different communities together in a single volume makes it possible to appreciate the mosaic of human issues more fully and forces us to anticipate the challenges that may arise -- and that will require our attention -- as the genetic revolution proceeds... A much needed antidote to the current genetic hoopla." -- Doris Teichler Zallen, Journal of the American Medical Association

"A cautious look at the effects of genetic discoveries on society... The issues raised by this book are valid, and all scientists should be aware of them. I often found myself nodding in agreement." -- Jeffrey C. Long, New England Journal of Medicine

"The authors present several thought-provoking issues in regard to prenatal genetic screening and selective abortion. It's a great contribution to the field." -- Fernando I. Rivera, Contemporary Sociology

"This book superbly and successfully fills its purpose -- to show the need for dialogue between researchers, health care professionals, communities, and individuals regarding various aspects of genetic technology." -- Choice

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 312 pages
• Publisher: The Johns Hopkins University Press (September 3, 2002)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0801869641
• ISBN-13: 978-0801869648
• Product Dimensions: 9.4 x 6 x 1.1 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.2 pounds
• Average Customer Review: No customer reviews yet. Be the first.
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #3,275,511 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)