Amazon.com Review
Until some scientific Babe Ruth perfects a prudent technique for time travel, the best way to experience a past rich with flavor and immediacy remains through access to primary, contemporary sources. The way it brings the past into the present,
Early Innings should bill itself as a tour guide for armchair travel into baseball's beginnings and infancy.
Essentially, it's a scrapbook--carefully researched and assembled--of the game's evolution from the earliest published report of a "bass-ball" challenge match between Upstate New York teams in 1825 to the 1901 birth of the American League and the spurious 1908 report on the origin of the game that pitched the myth of Cooperstown and Abner Doubleday. Sullivan's sources run the bases from newspaper and periodical accounts to letters to excerpts from such documents as "Spalding's Official Baseball Guide," each packaged with individual introductions to lend context to the text.
Combining serious scholarship and fascinating journalism, Early Innings covers the kind of territory good center fielders dream of. Some of its more curious bits of ephemera: the first published account--with something resembling a box score--of a ball game in a New York paper from 1845; an 1856 defense of the game as a "manly exercise"; the 1862 obituary of James Creighton, one of the game's prehistoric stars; Henry Chadwick's 1867 "Ancient History of Baseball" (with, not surprisingly, no mention of Doubleday or Cooperstown at all); the document excluding blacks from the National Association of Base Ball Players; William Hulbert's original proposal to form the National League; a chronicle of the first game played under the lights--informally, in Nantucket; the rule change setting the current distance between the plate and the mound; John McGraw's defection from the Baltimore Orioles to the New York Giants; and the Boston Globe's account of Cy Young's defeat in the opening game of the first World Series. As extensive as it is appealing, Early Innings informs, instructs, entertains, and amazes, just like the game it sheds its light on. --Jeff Silverman
From Library Journal
The University of Nebraska Press, which has brought back to print several classic baseball books in the past few years, now offers this original collection of fascinating documents that brings seldom-seen sources to the fingertips of historians and serious fans. The arrangement is chronological, beginning with the earliest known newspaper account of baseball in 1825 and concluding with the reports published in 1908 crediting Abner Doubleday with the founding of the sport. There are many gems here that are normally not available to baseball historians without access to research libraries. Some documents are less useful (e.g., do we really need to see "Casey at the Bat" again?). The language used in the contemporary accounts is somewhat archaic but should not put off readers. On balance, this is a worthwhile addition for the baseball collections of public and school libraries.
William O. Scheeren, Hempfield Area H.S. Lib., Greensburg, Pa.
Copyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
See all Editorial Reviews
by Dean A. Sullivan
by Jules Tygiel
by Tom Simon
