Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A disappointing end to the Lionboy trilogy, January 10, 2006
As an editor, I had high hopes for Lionboy: the Truth. I had really enjoyed the first instalment, Lionboy (a book with action, characterisation, and plenty of zing), and the second, Lionboy: the Chase, was also exciting and well written. The Truth, however, is lost in the telling. While this book was a nice adventure and, indeed, a necessary wrap-up to the series, I had to force myself to read it. I didn't care about the characters, many of whom seemed empty and flat. Several characters seemed altogether unnecessary. Claudio, for example, seems to simply be along for the ride - his character does not develop, and he plays no important role. Primo makes a superfluous appearance after setting out from Venice, then he disappears mid-story. The Young Lion and Elsina set out on a quest to help Charlie, but really don't achieve much, and also don't develop as characters. Maccomo's character was great - a powerful, frightening villain. But, mid-book, he too becomes passive, until he is quietly arrested at the end. Others, like Madame Baliene and the Eagle serve fleeting purposes - an example of events that bog down the story. And why, why, why does the Circe arrive at the end? So that we can catch up with old characters?
Another irritating feature is the narrator's momsy voice. The text is crammed with the author's moral opinions - her opposition to cloning was repeated ad nauseam. Other messages, such as `pollution is bad,' `stealing is wrong,' `loyalty is good,' `slavery is bad' etc, made me think gee, thanks for the tip, as I heard them again and again.
The biggest flaw was that all of the peril and suspense in this story takes place in the beginning. Towards the end of the story, I simply didn't feel any sense of threat. Convenient plot twists mean that the young protagonist simply coasts to the finish line, stepping over brief, tacked-on obstacles that resolve themselves far too quickly (when Ninu was carried off I thought finally, some action - but he was back in a heartbeat - I didn't even have time to fret. There was a strong feeling of deja-vu when Elsina was shot - only to get straight back up again). The book finished with an abrupt, too-easy ending.
Yes, there were some nice moments, some nice description and some nice action, but the Truth was simply not on par with its predecessors.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A little disappointing, May 14, 2006
The first two books in the trilogy series were fast-paced and fun. Unfortunately, this wasn't really the case with the final book (Lionboy: The Truth). The story seemed to just drag on and then at the end everything happened at once. It seemed that only parts of the book were good while the rest was slow, irrelevant and unnecessary. However, I would still recommend that you read the book so you know what happens at the end of the trilogy series.
|
|
|
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A satisfying conclusion to the Lionboy Trilogy, September 23, 2005
The second volume in the Lionboy series ended with Charlie Ashanti, the Catspeaker, finally reunited with his parents. The evil lion trainer Maccomo has gotten his comeuppance, and only troublemaking Rafi Sadler left to worry about. Everything is great, right?
Not for long, as Charlie is soon kidnapped, and he and his parents become involved in a high-speed Atlantic Ocean pursuit. Charlie's beloved lions get in on the act, and Charlie finally has his chance to confront the powerfully evil Corporacy --- but not before he must make some tough choices.
There are plenty of surprises along the way, including more discoveries about Charlie's family, some of them not entirely welcome. Charlie also learns more about his past, and even has an emotional --- and surprising --- reunion with the leopard responsible for his ability to speak the language of cats.
Like the first two volumes in the Lionboy series, LIONBOY: THE TRUTH unfolds at a breakneck pace, switching among characters, scenes, and even continents at a furious speed, keeping readers eager to discover what new adventures await Charlie and his friends. And he has a lot of friends, too: there's practically a cast of thousands, what with all the characters from the first two books reappearing, along with some new ones, such as the multilingual chameleon Ninu. It's no wonder that the book ends with a somewhat tongue-in-cheek update on every character's future plans, stretching out over several pages.
LIONBOY: THE TRUTH brings the Lionboy trilogy to a satisfying conclusion. Louisa Young and Isabel Adomakoh Young (aka Zizou Corder) have developed a thrilling fantasy world and a compelling hero in this old-fashioned adventure series with a high-tech spin. Here's hoping we haven't heard the last from this talented mother-daughter writing team!
--- Reviewed by Norah Piehl
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|