From Publishers Weekly
Living among the water lilies of Monet's country home, frogs Hector and Henriette and their tadpoles happily "pose" for the bearded artist who paints their pond each day. First-time author Sweeny sets up a rivalry between the frogs and a "Monsieur Crow" who thinks that it is he who is being immortalized on canvas; the crow is finally disillusioned one day when he "swooped down and began snapping up tadpoles in his sharp pointed bill.... All at once the old painter sent a stone flying across the pond." In spite of such ecodrama, however, this tale proves anticlimactic; it simply tapers off when "one spring, the old painter did not appear." Fain's (Handsigns) pointillistic paintings capture neither the spirit nor the subtleties of impressionism (compare Bijou le Tord's radiant A Blue Butterfly, also set in Giverny; Children's Forecasts, Sept. 18). Fain's stippled illustrations offer a sharp focus on the famous pond, which is depicted in a tart fuchsia-and-aqua palette. Readers can sample Monet's own take on his pond via a three-page gatefold reproduction of a 1920-1921 painting from the Water Lilies series. Ages 2-6.
Copyright 1995 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 3-Hector and Henriette, two of the most fashionable frogs in all of France, assume that the old man who comes to their pond is painting their portraits. They pose patiently until Monsieur Crow announces that the artist is in fact painting HIS portrait. Soon, with a growing family of tadpoles, the frogs have better things to think about, but they notice that the man comes back every spring for several years. In the years that follow, they tell their children and grandchildren how they posed for an old painter in a straw hat. This whimsical story with stylized colored-pencil drawings could serve well as support material for beginning art-appreciation endeavors. The book includes a facsimile of Monet's signature and a three-page gatefold reproduction of one of his water lily paintings. Other, more thorough treatments for a young audience include Christina Bjork's Linnea in Monet's Garden (Farrar, 1987), Bijou Le Tord's A Blue Butterfly (Doubleday, 1995), and Mike Venezia's Monet (Childrens, 1990).?Linda Wicher, Highland Park Public Library, IL
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
See all Editorial Reviews