Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
45 of 49 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
From the illustrator of the Tarzan comic strip..., August 14, 2002
I cut my teeth on drawing people with Burne Hogarth. He has analyzed the human figure in a brilliant manner. Despite this, I would recommend "Dynamic Figure Drawing" over this book. For starters, the first sixty pages are devoted to art history. Nothing wrong with this, but for people that want to get started on drawing the human figure, it's not necessary. Second, "Dynamic Figure Drawing" is more accessible for beginners. The forms of the body are broken down so the reader can see the shapes. I would buy this book after spending alot of time with "Dynamic Figure Drawing". There is relevant information in this book, but it's not for beginners.
|
|
|
26 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Perhaps the best ever "how to" book on creating action poses, August 27, 1999
By A Customer
The inimitable Burne Hogarth breaks down, with startling simplicity, the secrets and tricks behind inventing YOUR OWN dynamic action poses! Once you've mastered his techniques, you REALLY WON'T ever need reference again! As an artist (15 years illustrating), I can whole-heartedly reccomend this book to any other artists (especially aspiring comic and sequential artists), struggling with the difficulties of posing the human figure in deep perspective (and making it look right). While I'm not a big fan of Hogarth's style (all the drawings... hundreds of them... are rendered in his style), I was nonetheless SO blown away by the techniques he revealed that I went and bought ALL the other Hogarth books. For the experienced artist... the benefit is this: Burne Hogarth doesn't try and teach you how to draw like HIM. He shows you how to use what he knows, to better serve your OWN art. And his tricks are time tested! Well worth the investment.
|
|
|
27 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
5 Stars= Original Version; 1 Star= '03 Revision-Update, May 27, 2006
...The *original* version is in my Top 3 Burne Hogarth books. But in 2003, the new, *revised* version changed my 5-Star rating...
To make this simple: there are 2 versions of this book. The *original* version is ISBN 0823015513, 232 pages, and is predominantly black & white, with a few bronze & white drawings for a little splash of color. The original version is *brilliant*- and is widely considered a classic. The new *revised & expanded* version is ISBN 0823015521, 255 pages, and is a completely random mix of black & white, red-orange, bronze, grey, and sometimes blue-lined drawings. The original has copyright dates of 1958-1990(paperback)-2002. The revised & expanded version is copyrighted 2003- and is available today. Currently, both versions share the same reviews listing, hence my mixed 3-Stars.
Because there are 2 separate versions, I'll be giving 2 separate reviews.
1. '5 STARS'- Original Version: It really is great(!)- EVERY muscle of the figure is shown in brilliant, 3-dimensional perspective. How brilliant is this? To many, it's simply an introduction to Dynamic Figure Drawing, which is often considered Burne Hogarth's *best* book. But Dynamic Anatomy is much more than that. It's his very 1st book-1958, and it's the basis of everything he's ever taught in the Dynamic Drawing series. All 5 of his other books spring from this. Essential bits & pieces of those books are actually included & originated from here!
As much as I love Dynamic Figure Drawing, Dynamic Anatomy *does* do a few things better. The figures in Dynamic Anatomy tend to be a little more sharply delineated, clear, high-contrast, and detailed. Proportions are also very clearly detailed- in Dynamic Figure Drawing the emphasis isn't as sharp in this area. Dynamic Anatomy features fantastic close-up views of the figure's main parts- Dynamic Figure Drawing concentrates mainly on the interconnection of parts, as well as with brilliant, full-figure construction from memory. Both books get my *highest* recommendation!
And Dynamic Anatomy really is a classic. Even Marvel's legendary John Buscema recommends it- check out his bibliography in How to Draw Comics the Marvel Way. It's important to note that he never saw the 2003 update of this book, so his recommendation is referring to the brilliant *original* version only. He also recommends a few George Bridgman books to go along with this- definitely a great idea!
2. '1 STAR'- 2003- Revised & Expanded Version: An interesting but absolute *mess*! What in the world were they thinking?!?
Goodness gracious alive, I can't stand this book now. As mentioned above, this book is a complete & total random mess of color. We get black & white, red-orange, bronze, grey, and sometimes blue-lined drawings- an especially hideous example of 'revision & expansion'. Nobody in this WORLD can convince me that Burne Hogarth would've wanted it to be seen like this.
Consider this- Burne Hogarth created this book in 1958- he passed away in 1996. He had about 38 years to make whatever changes he wanted, and guess how many changes he ended up making in all this time? Zero. Zip. Zilch. Nada. Absolutely NONE. Apparently he was happy with it exactly as it was. Yet not even 10 YEARS after he passes away, the Hogarth family decides to change it. Even with the *best* of intentions- this is morally & ethically wrong. Even the BEST intentions here can't make this 'wrong' a 'right'.
Do we 'honor' artists by changing their work? Do we 'honor' Michelangelo & Da Vinci by 'revising & expanding' what they did? No! We preserve it- maybe restore it- but we never... EVER... change what they did. But we have good intentions right? Let's break apart Michelangelo's sculpture of David, and then reassemble it with a few new parts, gluing it all together with a bright orange, neon epoxy! Not a good idea you say? Well it just happened to Burne Hogarth's Dynamic Anatomy! And it's truly made a mess of a brilliant work of art.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|