Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
familiar, but very different, July 6, 2005
Having graduated from the same missionary boarding school as Palmer, but over a decade later (I think), our experiences were quite different. Although we still ate from metal trays in the 1980's, there were neither metal fragments or worms in our cafeteria meals. This barely fictional account vividly describes the wonder and beauty some of us found as children in Africa, while candidly portraying the inner conflict felt by many missionaries and their children as a balance is sought between "God's work" and what is best for the family.
Perhaps in part because I entered boarding school as a teenager and not a small child, I never felt the abandonment the characters in this book describe, but I had friends and siblings whose memories are not as warm as mine and who struggled for years to come to terms with being "sent away".
This book will touch raw nerves for many involved with missions and that will be a good thing if it opens eyes and hearts to the often unspoken needs and hidden pain of missionary children. As a public school teacher in the U.S., I see many children in pain and with difficult or even awful lives, but missionary children are sometimes the last ones to show their pain because it's so important to put on a happy face.
I could go on and on...obviously this book moved me deeply. The only reason I did not give 5 stars was that I hope people don't think that the school represented by "KCA" in the book is the way Palmer describes it. If it ever was that bad, it changed long ago. For a thorough history of the school, Rift Valley Academy, see "School in the Clouds," by Phil Dow, another alumnus.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wow! Finally!, September 11, 2002
By A Customer
The Happy Room captures the contradictions and confusions which children of missionaries often, if not usually, experience both as children and adults. As the daughter, granddaughter and sister of missionaries, I am thrilled to see this material dealt with in a novel. Often more truth can be told in fiction than in straight biography. This cogent work hits the issues, from abandonment to spiritualization of feelings, with honesty, insight, grace and balance. A few years ago I read The Poisonwood Bible with hope that it would deal with the psychological effects of the Missionary Kid (MK) experience. But it was written by an observer, not one who lived it, and while it was a fascinating novel, it seemed to me to be a distortion of missionary life. The Happy Room is an accurate portrate. The Happy Room will be on the psychologist's, counselor's, pastor's, and hopefully even the missions professor's bookshelf, not to mention that of every MK who is fortunate enough to include it in his or her journey. I recommend this book to young people feeling "called" to the mission field, and to their mentors, professors, and pastors. I recommend it to any frined, spouse, or grown child of a "Third Culture Kid." I recommend it to all TCK's with one foot in each of two cultures and at home in neither; to all ACM's (Adult Children of Missionaries) especially when the reason given was "doing God's will." I recommend it for discussion in support groups, 12 step groups, and Bible Studies. I recommend it to ponder, laugh and cry over in private. Thank you, Catherine, thank you for telling our story!
|
|
|
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
WOW! A moving and thought-provoking book., February 23, 2002
This book is inspired. Catherine Palmer wrote this book from the heart. It is quite different from much Christian fiction in that it offers no simple answers other than showing the human need for faith in the divine. The main characters in this book are the adult children of missionary parents. The children struggle with the concept that they felt abandoned by their parents while the parents were following their own 'calling from God.' The children grow up with a mixture of faith, anger, and resentment, trying to make their own way in the adult world of the US that is so foreign to the Africa where they grew up. In the end, the children and parents come to some understanding of each other, but there are significant difficulties that remain. They learn to accept the human failings of each other. They grow in their faith, but their faith does not protect them from earthly struggles. I am a clinical psychologist and my patients frequently discuss spiritual crises. I am frequently recommending this book because of its honesty.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|