|
|
79 of 86 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Wrong title, but still interesting, December 21, 2002
By A Customer
The title is a bit of a misnomer. This is not, per se, a book about Goth. It certainly doesn't touch very much on "Goth Chic". The alternate title is more revealing: "A Connoisseur's Guide to Dark Culture", and it's THIS that you should keep in mind. The author makes it known from the beginning that Goth is a very difficult thing to nail down. Is it Specimen/Batcave Bauhaus/art-rock Sisters Of Mercy/dark rock subculture? An extension of punk? Where do Industrial crossovers and bands like Dead Can Dance fit in? So he decides to roll the dice and talk about as much that has been touched by a "Gothic" aesthetic as possible, and that includes black metal (Cradle of Filth), industrial (Nine Inch Nails), and some silly Spanish band called Gothic Sex whose lead singer you have to see to believe. There's also quite a bit of backstory, so you get details about Byron, Baudelaire, expressionist horror film, EC comics, etc. Therefore, the book doesn't just talk about Goth (however you interpret it - you being a Bauhaus purist, or Sunshine Blind fan) - it also talks about Black Metal, Death Rock, Horror Films, EC Comics, BDSM, vampire wannabees, etc. and in true liberal arts fashion traces the undercurrents, commonalities, and divergences that separate the different threads that have descended from the Byrons, Baudelaires, Decadents and Romantics that got the dark ball rolling in the first place(so for those of you thinking "Goth" started with Marilyn Manson, you're wrong on two counts... the first being what I just mentioned, the second being that Marilyn Manson is NOT Goth but a HEAVY METAL ARTIST and ALICE COOPER RIPOFF and thankfully, this book gets that right.) Looking for info just on Goth? Well, it's there but it's scattered around a lot and mixed in with info about a lot of other similar subcultures. That having been said, though, I did learn quite a few things reading the book, and it was worth the read (for example, colour me stupid, but I had no idea it was Peter Murphy in that "blown away" Maxell ad in the 80s) I'm surprised at the fact that even when non-Goth stuff gets mentioned (e.g. black metal, BDSM or those silly LARPer people dancing around in glow in the dark fangs "oo! oo! What clan are you?") the guy has a clue enough to mention that it isn't Goth. This isn't the definitive guide to Goth. I don't think that's been written. It IS worth the read, so if you come across it, give it a look.
|