Coolidge: An American Enigma (Hardcover)

~ Robert Sobel (Author) "AMERICAN INTELLECTUALS DO NOT so much harbor a negative opinion of Calvin Coolidge as they trivialize him..." (more)
Key Phrases: White House, Calvin Coolidge, United States (more...)

Editorial Reviews

From Publishers Weekly

In this inflated revisionist biography, Sobel seeks to overturn the image of Calvin Coolidge as a taciturn, do-nothing president. He portrays his subject as an embodiment of the ethos of a vanished America, a pragmatic politician who espoused a philosophy of a passive executive branch. Although Coolidge took no actions to promote race relations, never spoke out against the Ku Klux Klan and passed a restrictive immigration bill that singled out Japanese for exclusion from entering the U.S., the 30th president is presented here as a champion of civil rights because, in Sobel's verdict, his public utterances in support of black Americans were outspoken and liberal-minded. There is some unintentionally hilarious understatment: "Coolidge's humor was not of the kind that causes belly laughs." And the author brings William Allen White to the president's defense by quoting him as saying, "Coolidge... was not dumb." In this lively but unpersuasive reappraisal, Sobel (Dangerous Dreamers) is mostly preaching to the converted. His broader themeAa refutation of the negative view of the Republican 1920s Harding-Coolidge-Hoover trio as a dismal interregnum between Wilson and FDRAis likewise debatable. Coolidge's presidency, despite Sobel's intentions, comes off as a wasteland of missed opportunities.
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.

From Library Journal

Noted business historian Sobel (Dangerous Dreamers, LJ 5/1/93) here attempts a revisionist examination of Calvin Coolidge, 30th president of the United States. Arguing that Coolidge "merits serious consideration," Sobel asserts that he was more complex than conventional wisdom would have us believe. Tracing Coolidge from New England childhood to retirement, he attempts to show "Silent Cal" as more of a "hidden-handed" type of leader than most historical assessments suggest. Unfortunately, his efforts to elevate Coolidge's reputation succeed only marginally. The Coolidge presented here had a Whig vision of presidential leadership and did not seek actively to lead the government. While this vision may have been, as Coolidge himself seemed to believe, closer to the original design of the Founders, it was probably better suited to the 19th than the 20th century. Still, Sobel succeeds at getting the reader to take a serious look at this oft-neglected and sometimes disparaged president, and his tightly argued, well-researched book will be of importance to historians and presidential scholars for years to come.AMichael A. Genovese, Loyola Marymount Univ., Los Angeles
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 400 pages
• Publisher: Regnery Publishing, Inc. (May 25, 1998)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0895264102
• ISBN-13: 978-0895264107
• Product Dimensions: 9.3 x 6.5 x 1.5 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.7 pounds
• Average Customer Review: 4.5 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (29 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #484,342 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

29 of 30 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars Only a Beginning. . ., July 19, 2004

By	J Keistler "[e-mail]" (Lake Jackson, Texas USA) - See all my reviews (TOP 500 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)

Amazon Verified Purchase

How interesting that as we look at the last century, President Coolidge has become a polarizing figure. After smears from William Allan White, Arthur Schlesinger and others, Coolidge has finally merited re-evaluation. While not an activist President in the vein of, say, Franklin Roosevelt, Coolidge was far from indolent or passive. He gave more press conferences than any other, inaugurated the use of radio, and sponsored airplanes in the military. However, it was indeed his belief that government should exist for the people, not the other way 'round. Interestingly, he was the last President to refuse to have a telephone in the Oval Office--he considered it undignified. He supported women's suffrage and his wife, Grace, was the first First Lady to smoke in the White House. I have undertaken to read many accounts of Coolidge; he does remain a mystery to us in so many ways. Regardless of the slant of the source, though, his deep sense of decency and honor in performing public service always shines through. I'd recommend purchasing a copy of 'Grace Coolidge and Her Era' from 1962 to give a more human side to both the President and his wife. Another characteristic of this man is that despite his reserve, his overriding love for his wife and sons remains there. The heartbreak that he and Mrs. Coolidge endured with the needless death of their youngest son in the White House cannot be overstated. Especially since we know now that the Staph. infection from which young Calvin died would nowadays have certainly not been fatal. I think part of the reason the Coolidge times have become fascinating for those of us interested in history is the obscurity to which these years have been consigned. The terms of FDR with his extensive radio and movie coverage has overshown the previous three Republican administrations, not by accident. I have concluded that no one book can cover all the aspects of President Coolidge, and he deserves further reading.

21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Keep Cool With Coolidge!, November 9, 1999

By	J. M. Croll (Mariposa, California) - See all my reviews

In this time of scandal, mud-slinging, political incompetence, and too-rapid change, the life of Calvin Coolidge is a nostalgic and refreshing reminder of a simpler time, and a simpler America. This 'accidental' President, who epitomized the quiet dignity and sound judgement Americans expected of their President, presided over unprecedented economic growth and a sense of national propriety and dignity. Following the disgrace of the Harding mis-Administration, Coolidge brought about a reformation of the executive branch, restored faith in the government, and skillfully asserted his control over the Republican Party. His willing retirement at the conclusion of his term exemplifies the 'citizen politician' once prevalent, and now virtually extinct. Much like the monumental biography of Harry Truman by David McCullough which led to a nostalgia for Truman, this biography is sure to do the same for Coolidge.

12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars An excellent study of "Silent Cal" and the "Roaring 20s"..., September 29, 2001

By A Customer

Calvin Coolidge, who served as President from 1923-1929, has long been rated as a "poor" President by liberal historians and academics who fault him for his seemingly passive, quiet, and inactive approach to the Presidency. In this first-rate biography, Mr. Sobel shows us just how wrong those judgements are. Far from being a "Silent" or "Lazy" President, Coolidge ran a remarkably honest and efficient Administration that led America through one of the most exciting and prosperous decades in American history - the "Roaring Twenties". As Sobel demonstrates, Coolidge was born and raised in an environment which the great majority of Americans today would find alien. He grew up in the tiny rural village of Plymouth, Vermont. His beloved mother died when he was young and he was raised by his father, a classic "pillar of the community" type - his father was serious, sober, religious, a prosperous farmer and general-store owner, and a local politician who served as a justice of the peace, constable, and Vermont state legislator. Coolidge grew up to be an equally serious-minded and self-reliant young man - a modern Puritan, without the hypocrisy or self-righteous attitude. Coolidge became a good lawyer in Northampton, Massachussetts, married Grace Goodhue and had a happy marriage, and slowly but steadily climbed the political ladder. Unlike most modern politicians who try to start out with a major office (such as Senator or Governor) and then immediately try to run for President, Coolidge spent many years in local and state politics before he became a "big-time" politician - a fact which probably accounted for his success as President. He served as a city councilman, Mayor of Northampton, state legislator, head of the Massachussetts State Assembly, Lieutenant Governor, Governor, and finally Vice-President and President. During his long climb Coolidge was never dramatic or spectacular, but he was intelligent, efficient, honest, reliable, and a good speaker. People seemed to like and trust him wherever he went, and his dry yet biting wit, and his quiet and reserved personality became legendary (in one famous story, Coolidge went to a party and said nothing. The hostess, desperate, approached him and said "Mr. President, I made a bet with my friend over there that I could get at least 3 words out of you tonight". Coolidge's reply: "You lose"). What this biography does is to give the reader a much better appreciation for the man, and Sobel convincingly demonstrates that the great economic boom of the 1920's was not merely a fluke, but the direct result of Coolidge's shrewd business sense and leadership. Anyone who continues to rate Coolidge as a poor President should be required to read this book and refute Sobel's persuasive arguments. To sum up, this is a first-rate book about a much-underrated President, and it should be highly recommended to all political and presidential history buffs.