|
|
44 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Reply to reviewers who are of Chinese descent, May 14, 2001
As author of SPLENDID SLIPPERS I was not surprised to read these two recent reviews by women of Chinese descent, which are factually absolutely incorrect. Sadly they have been badly misinformed by elder relatives who are needlessly ashamed of the custom of footbinding, or themselves were honestly ignorant of the actual facts. Or possibly the reviewers are of Manchu rather than Han Chinese descent. When the Manchu invaded China in 1644, the Emperor forbid Manchu women from binding their feet. Only the Han Chinese, and many of the Minority People, bound. So Manchu women may not know the true facts of footbinding.I spent almost seven years researching the subject of footbinding before writing my book. I have read hundreds of books with information on the subject, and traveled through China many times, with English-speaking Chinese guides, interviewing a tremendous number of older women with bound feet, and their husbands. Photos of several of them, which tell the story better than I can here, appear in the book. And may I say not one of these elderly women I interviewed with tiny lotus feet had ever seen more than a life of poverty in mountain huts or little villages, rising at before sunrise helping to care for her family, and after marriage her own children, husband and husband's parents, foraging for firewood, working in the rice fields,yam fields, or whatever poor little crops the families tried to raise, since they were little girls with newly bound feet. As I explain in my book, in the beginning period of footbinding (approximately 950 AD) only women in the palace bound their feet, then the custom spread to minor nobility. Eventually it spread to the newly rich merchant class. However, by the 17th century about 96% of all Han Chinese girls had their feet bound. Chinese experts estimate that more than four and one half BILLION Han Chinese, and some Minority People women, have bound their feet the past 1,000 years. In cities such as Peking, Canton and Shanghai, and other wealthy areas, there were of course affluent women and they did indeed have bound feet. But the majority of the women of China have always been the peasants who live at poverty, or almost poverty, level. And the majority of them for 1,000 years had bound feet.
|