|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Academic and thoughtful, but fatally flawed, February 5, 1999
By A Customer
A sober, well-written and well thought out set of instructions by someone whose knowledge of the singles market is clearly secondhand. Nice psychology. Some wonderful truths. Yes, G. Clayton, being a good man wanting to fall in love means I have a wonderful gift for someone. And there are others that are wonderfully affirming. But here's the rub. You say that women would consider the most romantic place to meet a man to be the New York subway system. That women would welcome a potential love-of-their-life in the grocery store, bookstores, art galleries, whatever. Makes good sense, and I bet lots of women would agree or even volunteer these things. But to paraphrase Mammy in a certain 1939 movie, what women want and what they say they want is two different things. In my recent 2 1/2 year-long being single experience, top-quality women are as receptive to meeting men for romance in daily life as your publisher would have been to receive the manuscript for this book written in crayon on construction paper. These women go to bars - regardless of their socioeconomic status. They log on to chat rooms. They meet men through friends. They go to singles events (though that's rare for attractive women with good careers under 45). They occasionally let someone in when their guard gets taken down by stressful events, such as those who marry the security guard who helped them when their car was stolen. And in life as it is, rather than life as some think it should be, that's about it. Makes sense, too. If you were a successful, attractive and smart early-30's woman, would you want to go through life looking at everyone, in romantically-available mode, all the time? You would get 20-50 men EVERY DAY hitting you up - you couldn't do anything else. And as for my wonderful gift, about which I sincerely agree with you, if the woman has the epidemic disease of fear and hostility toward intimacy, it will end up ungiven. With all of that said, the book is heartening and useful. A good and worthwhile read.
|