|
|
88 of 119 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Insightful and Thought-Provoking, January 1, 2003
From old Omni magazine to current Scientific American and Discover magazines, books and online sources, I have watched Big Bang theory from the sidelines as it has developed over the years. Initially, it made sense, but as the years progressed, especially in the years after the Hubble Space Telescope opened the far heavens to us. I've read the articles, I've seen tweak after tweak over the years, claims of past ability to predict (such as the temperature of the microwave background radiation at 2.7 K) that I know weren't agreed upon until after it was measured, and the like.The real affront of current-day Big Bang Theory, however, seems to be reflected in a purported quote of Paul Dirac's: "It is more important to have beauty in one's equations than to have them fit experiment" (I doubt Dirac was quite so single-minded, but interviews definitely have him enamoured with such 'beauty') - the seeming belief that nature will bend to equations, rather than the other way around. This book of Mr. Mitchell's is a clear, compelling tour of the troubles of Big Bang Theory, a survey of alternatives, and a reasonable alternative of his own. It is an interesting, accessible look at the history of Big Bang Theory, the assumptions it makes, the contradictions it has had to deal with (age of the universe versus age of the most distant structures we can see), the telescope observations that get swept under the carpet, the politics, and some special attention to Big Bang Theory's somwhat new addition, Inflation Theory, and how this extension solves some problems, but seriously complicates others. There is a lot of repetition in this book, some typos and some spots with emotionally charged language. There is also a plethora of readily accessible math, clear explanations, good organization, a bevy of TLAs (three-letter acronyms - seemingly unavoidable with all things astronomical) and some interesting astronomical observations. Looking for the actual origin of the universe? You won't find it here, but you will find some compelling reasons to push the origin back, and you'll likely not look at Big Bang Theory in the same light ever again. A highly recommended read.
|