|
|
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
russ Columbo: Lou Miano's time capsule, July 23, 2001
Mr. Lou Miano has done an excellent job in documenting and producing a highly readable book which should satisfy all of Russ Columbo's fans as well as aficionados of the Hollywood and New York vaudeville and theater scenes of the 1930's. Without the sentimentality one would normally anticipate in such a commemorative book, Miano sets forth a colorful tapestry for his reporting of Russ's family background, his parents, siblings, his education, and youthful ambitions. Their ethnicity, struggles, familial losses, uprooting, and personal sacrifice are so effectively portrayed that one develops an intimacy with the Columbo family. Similarly, the minutely detailed descriptions of Russ's early and later struggles and successes in New York and Hollywood, most effectively aided by copious photographs, copies of personal and business letters, playbills, theater posters, film frames and all sorts of priviledged documentation, creates a three-dimensionality that the book makes one feel like "they were there with Russ."Miano lets the material tell the story. He rarely interjects personal opinions or insights that one would expect from a less honest biographer. But he makes sure that he includes quotes from Russ or his associates which address and settle questions that the reader may have. For example, as a music collector I have had two questions regarding Russ's singing and his orchestra; "were the humming verses he employed derived in any way from his experience as a violinist?" While Miano reports that his fans enjoyed these highly creative flourishes, he makes no effort to explain their derivation. Instead, he more effectively employ's a quote from Russ himself who confirms that he used the violin obligato parts for his vocal excursions. The second item that always bothered me was the apparent anonymity of the personnel in his great dance band coupled by their great sound, arrangements, and dance beat. I checked the expert sources for such information, i.e., Albert McCarthy's book "The Dance Band Era" (a picture of Russ but no mention of his orchestra at all). Next I check with Brian Rust's discography "American Dance Bands"...again not even a mention. Mr. Miano comes to the rescue here with a complete identification of that orchestra's personnel (which included Jimmy McPartland, Benny Goodman, and Gene Krupa among other notables...and twin pianos) no wonder the reviewers and dancers alike raved about this band...again information provided by Miano. Imagine the dance beat that Krupa and two pianos would generate! I hopt that Brian Rust gets to read Miano's book and makes the appropriate additions to his highly regarded discography. This book is so full of so many important details and so devoid of wasteful "fluff" that the reader will come away richly rewarded by gaining a new intimacy with Russ, his films and recordings via two great discographies (these alone are worth the book's price). I could go on but I will just be keeping you from picking up your copy and immersing yourselves in this worthwhile book. Upon completing this book I predict that you will be as impressed as I was with the fact that Russ Columbo accomplished so much in his short 26 years. Clearly the substance put together in this book by Miano justifies this impression. Finally, I hope that Jim Bedoian of TAKE TWO RECORDS gets to read this book and becomes inspired to produce a second CD covering Russ's commercial recordings, transcriptions, air checks, etc., that were not contained on either his first CD or the ASV CD.
|