Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not too impressed by the writing, but the art is magical!, February 28, 2006
Personally, I think both Feist's Wood Boy and Williams' Burning Man are told better in the text version. While the art does add some definition to some parts of the story, and it is kind of nice to put faces and expressions to the names in the stories, I think it is obvious that these stories were not meant for the comic book format. By breaking up the writing into small bubbles, and relying on the artist for so much of the feel of the story, a lot of the original magic is lost. This is not to blame either the artists (who couldn't have done a better job in my opinion) or the writers. I just think it is hard to bring a novella such as those found in the Legends Anthology to the comic book format.
The Wood Boy is the tale of a small boy in the realm of Feist's Riftwar Saga that lives in a town taken by the Tsurani. As he learns to cope with living as a slave, and as he falls in love with his lord's daughter, the 'wood boy' begins to feel resigned to his fate under his new masters. When one of his only friends betrays his own and kidnaps(?) the lord's daughter, the boy finds himself setting out on a dangerous journey with nothing to loose and nowhere to go. The story ends as a promise for more to come.
In The Burning Man, a lonely girl named Breda is confused by nearly everything that has happened in her life. When she finds out that her cold acting stepfather has captured a witch and seems to be planning on hurting her, Breda goes stealth and witnesses her lover betraying his master. (Interesting both of these stories revolve around unexpected betrayals). This story is told in a narrative form with a much older Breda speaking to the reader of a time long past and includes much more text boxes providing some extra background and setting info.
Still a quick and fun read with really great art, but not a replacement for the original stories.
|
|
|
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantasy done right!, November 28, 2005
This graphic novel contains two stories from the LEGENDS anthology, which was also where readers were first introduced to George R. R. Martin's THE HEDGE KNIGHT, which has been done as another fantastic graphic novel by the same company. Both stories are extremely faithful to the source text and the spirit of the original style of storytelling.
The first story, THE WOOD BOY, is written by Raymond E. Feist as is a side story to the Riftwar Saga. It's about a young boy named Dirk who becomes a slave when an invading army occupies the estate where he works. The first chapter is all about the changes in his life as the army prepares for a long winter, but the second chapter shifts gears abruptly when all of the other slaves are betrayed and murdered by one of their own and Dirk charges off to save the Lord Paul's daughter, whom the traitor kidnapped. In the process, he develops a special kind of courage in his zeal to be a hero.
The second story, THE BURNING MAN, was written by Tad Williams and takes place in the same world as his epic series MEMORY, SORROW AND THORN. It's about a girl named Breda who is on the verge of becoming a woman as she lives in the haunted High Keep with her stepfather, the dominating Sulis the Apostate. But Sulis has a dark secret that involves her lover, the young soldier Tellarin, and Breda vows to protect them both as she follows them one eerie night and encounters the strange being she calls the Burning Man.
Both stories feature fantastic art by comic book veterans -- the former by Mat Broome and the latter by Brett Booth. The back of this edition also features a preview of Raymond E. Feist's MAGICIAN, which is also drawn by Booth.
The book looks fantastic, with high production values and bright colors. It's a must-read for anyone who enjoys fantasy, comics, or both!
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
amazing illustration, November 10, 2006
I was not aware that I was buying an Illustrated or Graphic novel when I purchased this. I was greatly pleased at the illustration to go along with the story. I had read The Wood Boy in the Legends Series but to add the illustrations made it come to live. As for the Burning Man, reading this graphic novel urged me to read more of Tad Williams also. I would highly recommend this.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Raymond E. Feist
by Raymond E. Feist
by Raymond E. Feist
by Raymond E. Feist
