From School Library Journal
Grade 2-6–Twenty-three competitors, ranging from the celebrated (Muhammad Ali, Michael Jordan, Joe DiMaggio) to the less familiar (Diego Maradona, Michael Schumacher, Annika Sorenstam) are presented on colorful spreads. Each one is introduced with a phrase that reflects the book's title and highlights a defining characteristic (e.g., for Wayne Gretzky, Athletes are made of brains over brawn). A lively paragraph offers a cursory look at a personal event or anecdote that emphasizes that particular trait, describing both accomplishments and foibles. Gouache collage portraits are decorated with items that cleverly reflect each individual's profession and personality. For instance, Babe Ruth (Athletes are made of a hunger for greatness) has Coke-bottle eyebrows, baseball gloves and balls for eyes, a large steak for a nose, and a hot dog with bun for a mouth. Surprisingly, these pictures actually do look like the subjects. Brief biographical facts about each athlete and a small photo are appended. While not a first purchase, this title is fun to browse. It could also inspire students to create self-portraits using items that expose their personalities, likes, and strengths, or to make a similar book about their favorite people. Make sure the art staff sees this one.
–Kate Kohlbeck, Randall School, Waukesha, WI Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
Gr. 2-4. Twenty-three sports figures, most of whom are still competing, are featured in this picture book for older children. Each athlete is presented in a full- or double-page illustration rendered in gouache and collage, accompanied by anecdotal information. The facial features of most of the athletes are depicted with items that relate to their sport or personal lives. Jesse Owens' eye is a bullet, which conveys his speed and shows that "athletes are made of get up and go." Tiger Woods holds a baby bottle, which demonstrates that "athletes are made of early starts." Martina Navratilova wears a Statue of Liberty crown to show that "athletes are made of free spirits." There is just enough information to appeal to sports fans (statistics and career highlights are given at the end in the "Post-Game Recap"), and the quirky, sometimes bordering on grotesque depictions of the athletes (Lance Armstrong looks like Frankenstein) will appeal to the visually inclined.
Randall EnosCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
See all Editorial Reviews