The Rejection Collection: Cartoons You Never Saw, and Never Will See, in The New Yorker (Hardcover)

~ Matthew Diffee (Editor), Robert Mankoff (Foreword)
Key Phrases: zebra ball, tires silo, fishing pole lobster, New York City, Potato Head, Tin Man (more...)

Editorial Reviews

Review

The submissions were not set aside because they were not funny but (for the most part) because they were too funny.

--New York Times --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.

Review

The submissions were not set aside because they were not funny but (for the most part) because they were too funny.

--New York Times

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 272 pages
• Publisher: Simon Spotlight Entertainment; 1st ed edition (October 3, 2006)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 1416933395
• ISBN-13: 978-1416933397
• Product Dimensions: 10.2 x 8.4 x 0.7 inches
• Shipping Weight: 2.2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 4.5 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (39 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #87,791 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

78 of 79 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars "The cream of the crap.", October 31, 2006

By	E. Bukowsky "booklover10" (NY United States) - See all my reviews (TOP 100 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)

"The Rejection Collection," edited by Matthew Diffee, consists of cartoons that were "too risque, silly, or weird" to be accepted by the New Yorker magazine. Diffee asked thirty of his friends and colleagues, all of whom have had their work published in the New Yorker, to sift through their rejects and submit their favorites. From these, Diffee picked HIS favorites, which he dubs "the cream of the crap."

Diffee inserts photographs of the artists as well as quirky questionnaires that allow the cartoonists to express their feelings about such topics as their childhoods, what makes them laugh, and how they handle rejection. Unsurprisingly, their answers tend to be offbeat, humorous, and filled with doodles. The cartoons themselves have to be seen to be believed. They are scatological, profane, sadistic, stupid, clever, politically incorrect, and often hilarious. It's fair game to satirize crooked politicians, cosmetic surgery, and idiotic voice mail messages, but how can anyone make fun of adultery, chemotherapy, transsexuals, child abuse, alcoholism, and suicide? Aren't these subjects off limits? It turns out that in some cartoonists' slightly warped minds, no subject must be avoided in the name of political correctness and good taste.

One of the book's strengths is the insight that it offers into the creative process. Some of the artists believe that the writing and the ideas are more important than the drawings--no ideas, no cartoons. However, in the best cartoons, the writing and drawing are so well integrated that neither element dominates. These cartoons work so well that the reader finds himself laughing out loud (and feeling guilty afterwards).

If you have a friend who is a bit wacky, irreverent, and not easily offended, this collection would make a good gift. I wouldn't give it to Mom, Dad, your rabbi, or your priest, however. In these pages are naked guys and ladies, references to bodily functions, and content that can euphemistically be described as inappropriate for people with delicate sensibilities. Although some of the cartoons simply fall flat, the best of the bunch effectively satirize modern society, the human condition, and the madness that surrounds us every day.

37 of 42 people found the following review helpful:

3.0 out of 5 stars The good with the bad, November 26, 2006

By	D. Low (Tucson) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

The cartoons in this book are mostly great, and I am very glad that Matthew Diffee decided to collect them between two covers for our benefit. However, what definitely weighs the book down are the interruptive cartoonist questionnaires which, although funny at times, reek of self-importance. As someone who takes great interest in cartoons and cartoonists, reading through the cartoonists' witticisms feels unnecessary even to me. One purchases a book of cartoons to see the cartoons, and the long Q&A sections that pepper the book simply destroy any sort of flow that it may have had. In general, cartoons which are funny individually become much funnier when looked at cumulatively (an idea that Stephen King hinted at in his introduction to one of the Far Side treasuries). Unfortunately, this book never allows itself to establish a one-after-another, hit-you-until-you're-down rhythm, and it suffers for it.

My advice to Mr. Diffee is to attempt to publish a second volume, 3rd, and 4th, etc., but without the cumbersome stoppages every three pages. There are clearly enough wonderful rejected cartoons out there to merit these volumes, and continuing to publish them is a fantastic idea, but the cartoonists' egos should be left at the door. Being a cartoonist is about showing off your work, not yourself.

If, however, somebody decided to compile biographical pieces on and photographs of New Yorker cartoonists, and not market the book as a book of cartoons, the questionnaires used in this tome would be highly appropriate and informative in that type of setting. Maybe that's another idea. But the two shouldn't be combined, because the reader is left wanting either way, not getting enough cartoons or biographical stuff.

20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Hilarious!, December 22, 2006

By	Phelps Gates (Chapel Hill, NC USA) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

Amazon Verified Purchase

These cartoons are much funnier than the ones which actually appear in the New Yorker. I usually laugh out loud two or three times per issue, but almost every cartoon in this book was a winner! Most of these cartoons were rejected not because of poor quality, but because they're in, ahem, questionable taste. The little questionnaires (full of sly wit) which each cartoonist answers were annoying at first, but ended up being one of my favorite parts of the book (partly because they stopped me from barreling through the cartoons and getting overloaded). A perfect gift for somebody who isn't easily offended!