|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent book for the beginning and intermediate wine lover -- and interesting for the expert as well, December 16, 2007
Robin Garr was a working newspaper reporter for more than 25 years, winning many journalism awards including a share of the Pulitzer Prize at "The Louisville Courier-Journal" in 1989. During that time he perfected an appealing, fact based style, perfectly suited to describing the complexities and joys of wine.
He started a wine column in the "Louisville Times" in 1980. He moved online to the CompuServe Wine Forum in 1985, and he has been online ever since. He currently maintains the fact filled Wine Lovers Page, "the oldest, largest and most popular independent wine-appreciation site on the World Wide Web!."
The "New York Times" says the site "outdoes all others" for its sheer quantity of friendly, well-written information about wine. The "Atlantic" agrees: "A comprehensive source of general wine information. Includes regular columns, a discussion forum, a question and answer area, recommended food-wine combinations, information about seasonal wines, wine-tasting tips, and more. Created by Robin Garr, a journalist and wine connoisseur."
The accolades are well deserved, and you can judge for yourself with this handy little collection of essays. Garr started the "30 Second Wine Advisor", an email wine letter, in 1999, which now appears three times a week, and has grown into a collection of nearly 2,000 articles. (Garr also publishes a FoodLetter on Thursday featuring recipes and food and wine pairings.)
This book collects some of the very best columns from that fire hose full of wine related words -- numbering in the millions according to the author. The essays are short, well written, and chosen to cover the essence of the topic covered. Like all good journalistic articles, the titles capture the essence of the essay, the meat is contained in the first few lines, and the body gives you enough information to understand the topic. The essays run between 200 and 500 words each, and taken together as a body of work, provide a comprehensive overview of wine and how to enjoy it.
"First things first: getting out the cork."
"Training your taster."
"Tasting the soil." [Or can you really do so?]
And from the every day practicalities to the big picture issues:
"Wine inflation."
"Will shipping laws ever change?"
"Alcohol levels climbing."
"Global warming in your glass."
Here's a good example of Garr's content and style, under the title: "A new wine serving ritual."
"For many of the wine enthusiasts who have already embraced the once-maligned metal screw cap as an appropriate seal for fine wines, its casual simplicity is part of the appeal of the alternative closure. Unscrew the cap, pour the wine; no muss, no fuss, and best of all, no snob factor.
"But wine lovers who enjoy the brief ritual that attends the extraction of the traditional cork feel that there's something missing in a quick, careless unscrewing. Indeed, for restaurant sommeliers, who make a living out of mastering wine minutiae, an opening procedure devoid of ritual could be a professional threat.
"No worries, mate ... those crafty sommeliers Down Under have already come up with a nifty little uncapping scheme that's sufficiently tongue-in-cheek to elicit more of a smile than a snobby sneer.
"The procedure is simple, much easier to master than the dreaded corkscrew: Grasp the cap firmly with one hand, and gently rotate the bottle under it with the other, breaking the seal with an audible, satisfying "crack." Then place the loosened cap against your forearm (tuxedo optional) and roll it down toward your hand, timing the move so the cap comes off just as the bottle rolls into your palm. Present the cap with a flourish if you wish. There's no need to sniff it, but you're welcome to do so if it pleases you.
"Is this ritual necessary? Of course not! Is it fun? I think so, although the answer to that question may depend on your sense of humor. The Aussie wine geeks who first told me about it thought it hilarious, and claimed it was an Australian invention, although my Kiwi wine pal Sue Courtney ([...]) insists that it came originally from New Zealand, in a video produced by the good folks at Villa Maria when they went over to the alternative closure years ago. One thing's certain: The idea almost had to come from Down Under, where producers in both countries have led the charge toward screw cap closures for wines of quality."
This is an excellent book for an beginning or intermediate wine lover with loads of information delivered in a very palatable style - a book for savoring and sipping. But, even as a wine lover with over 200 wine books in his library, and with a number of wine resources online, I found this series of essays a very useful overview of many of the factors in this fascinating field, and I've given a number of copies to friends who are interested in learning more about wine.
Best of all, this is a living book, in a very real sense. Garr has collected all of his essays -- and much more besides -- on the "Wine Lovers Page". If you are interested in exploring any topic in more depth, surf to that page, and search on the key words in the search engine box at the top.
All in all, I found this a very worthwhile book, which will encourage you to think about wine and your approaches to it - even when you don't agree with the author.
Robert C. Ross 2007 2008
|