Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
61 of 66 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A truly remarkable woodworking book, November 16, 2007
As an avid reader of Christopher Schwarz's various articles and columns in woodworking magazines, I've been awaiting the publication of this book with anticipation. Now that I've read it I have to say that it's better than I expected, and my expectations were very high.
I've read a number of books and articles on workbenches (notably the ones by Lon Schleining and Scott Landis, which are valuable for what they are: surveys of various styles of workbenches, with info on how to build a few of them). This book is different. Not just a little different. Radically different.
Schwarz is not just a good writer. He is an extremely good writer, vastly better than the majority of writers about woodworking; better than most writers, period. He is not merely capable of explaining things clearly, or of organizing his text coherently. His writing is actually enjoyable to read. He has the ability to combine highly technical information with a kind of narrative structure, within which personal experience, historical research and theoretical conceptualization come together almost seamlessly. One could describe the book as almost an essay in the classical, Montaignesque sense: a personal, spiraling account of a particular subject, whose compelling structure takes the reader along on a wide-ranging voyage of discovery, and makes the reader a companion of the author as he works out his own thinking. However, this should not be understood as saying that the book is in any way vague, for it isn't. I mean to underline its powerfully engaging quality. I believe somebody who wasn't a woodworker, who had no plans whatsoever to construct a workbench, would enjoy reading it.
Schwarz is also a gifted scholar and theoretician, a trait not typical of woodworkers, of writers about woodworking. The evidence of his thorough research and profound thought on his subject abounds in the book. His conceptualization of the workbench as a tool for holding lumber so that its 3 different surfaces (edges, faces, and ends) can be worked is a recognition that you won't find anywhere else, and one that animates the entire book. It may sound simple, even obvious, but so does the second law of thermodynamics.
The book provides designs and construction overviews of 2 very different benches, which may seem a paltry number of options. It is not. Schwarz has distilled years of research and bench-building into these 2 designs, and offers plenty of options along the way as to how one might alter them to suit one's own purposes. The illustrations are abundant, clear and useful. Numerous sidebars provide detailed and helpful insight into a variety of sub- or side-topics (eg. Find a source for yellow pine; Pattern-maker's vises: friend or foe?; The Stanley No. 203 - better than a peg). The index is extensive.
Anybody familiar with Schwarz from his hand-tool courses and DVDs knows that he is a formidable woodworker and teacher. Those qualities resound through this book, as does his engaging ability to be personal, as does his earnestness, as does his good humor. I've always learned easily from him, and this book continues that trend.
The first bench I ever built was from an article of Schwarz's called "The $175 Workbench," published in Popular Woodworking in 2000. I still have it, and use it every day. I will be building another one soon, using an adaptation of one of the designs outlined in this book; this book which will accompany me along the way, like a friend. Perhaps this sounds a bit loopy, but read the book and tell me you don't share the feeling.
|
|
|
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Valuable resource, a pleasure to read, November 26, 2007
I've followed along in Popular Woodworking and his blog as Christopher Schwarz has developed this book. I've seen Chris on TV and read a number of his contributions to other books on hand tools. He's always impressed me as an excellent teacher/writer but also as a serious student of the craft.
I was concerned that being so familiar with his work that I would be "re-reading" previously published material. I am happy to say that not only is the book full of information new to me but that it was a pleasure to read some of the familiar clips again.
To me the real value from this work is in gaining a sold understanding of "Why the workbench?" and how its design can be adapted to your kind of work to deliver so much additional pleasure in your work. There are two great heritage benches detailed in this book. Each can be easily constructed (easy as in technically easy - it is called "wood WORKing" after all). Either will likely remain for generations of craftsmen to use.
Finally, even though this is a "technical" work - it is a tremendous pleasure to read, witty and accessible. I have waited to read Christopher's book before building my bench. I'm glad I did and can't wait to start.
|
|
|
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Form Follows Function, December 5, 2007
This book is a must for anyone considering building, purchasing or modifying a woodworking bench. Even if you are not looking to change a bench, the information on holding work is invaluable. It is unique look at workbench design from the standpoint of the myriad of woodworking functions that can be performed on a bench. Christopher Schwarz' approach provides a wealth of information that helps the reader decide the features of a bench adapted to their own work. It is also a good read. The author's self deprecating humor is woven throughout as he compares and contrasts various features of bench design. This is a five star addition to any woodworker's library.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Popular Woodworking Editors
by Garrett Hack
by Sam Allen
by Leonard Lee
