Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
What have you done?, August 2, 1998
By A Customer
Everything we were led to believe in previous novels, including of course the entire Riftwar Saga, has been proven false. The Dragon Lords (Valheru) were, in fact, nothing but pawns from the beginning, Macros' entire existence was a lie. The "truth" about Macros hit me hardest of all. He was one of my favourite characters, and I liked the idea of this immeasurably-old, powerful magician (clearly god-like in his ability), travelling from world to world, never able to rest, always driven to solve the conflicts he cannot help but foresee. Now he is revealed as nothing more than a Keshian magician who was granted great power by the dead god of magic. He could not be more than five hundred years old. He of course had the power to time- and dimension-travel, explaining his appearance on Kelewan millenia before, and his having been remembered by the elf Tathar, but it is still disappointing and, I must say, a great let-down. Macros previously had this incredib! le mystique. He was old beyond measure and had powers, as I've said, to rival the gods. He had been able to battle (and survive) the Enemy, a creature of the combined life-essence of the Dragon Host. His true origin was very poorly executed and greatly lacking creativity. If Feist could not have found a better way to treat this great character, he should have left him where we last saw him in "A Darkness at Sethanon," departing Midkemia to pursue new challenges. Oh, the humanity!
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Appalling, sometimes it is better to stop writing., April 24, 2006
This book attempts to "reboot" the continuity of several major characters by changing their backstory in midstream. Mr Feist is faced with the problem writers face when their major characters become too powerful (Both Pug and Tomas are almost gods). You end up just inventing more and more powerful adversaries. At some point it becomes both tired and ridiculous. This is way past that point. Yet somehow I still kept reading. Sigh. I am sure there are still Midkemia stories to be told. But vast end-of-the-world stories should not be one of them. After all, just how many times can Midkemia be threatened with "the end to everything" before it becomes just another yawn.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A satisfying conclusion (?) to another great Feist saga, May 8, 1998
There is a difference in this saga than the former, and many have already mentioned that it seems to hurry along too much. I thoroughly enjoyed this series, but thought the ending was a little "too easy" and just too expected. I was hoping for something more. I disagree with others that say the characters were not interesting, i was happy to re-visit Pug, Calis and Tomas all over again. Alot of people also gripe about the revelation of mysteries previously proposed in the previous series. Well, as a long-time reader of sagas that just never die (DragonLance), I was thoroughly happy to finally learn WHO Macros, understand Miranda's history and I love the "Simpkin-like" (Weis/Hickman reference) character in Nakor. Everyone is a bit too critical, but i agree that it was sad to see Midkemia reduced to ruin. Parts of the story were EXTREMELY SAD, but then, all characters cannot live to be realistic. I feel Raymond's goal in this series was to put to rest an excellent era of life on Midkemia. Some have mentioned the posibility of another book, I feel one could be written, but this ROADK really seemed like an end-all to everything. Also, this has to be the most reviews I have ever seem on Amazon... wow!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Raymond E. Feist
by Raymond E. Feist
by Raymond E. Feist
by Raymond E. Feist
by Raymond E. Feist
