Against the Machine: The Hidden Luddite Tradition in Literature, Art, and Individual Lives (Hardcover)

by Nicols Fox (Author) "AMONG THE MANY ISLANDS OFF THE COAST OF Maine there is one called Placentia..." (more)
Key Phrases: technology resisters, rebels against the future, plain cottages, William Morris, Luddite Rebellion, John Muir (more...)

Editorial Reviews

Review
"[Fox] carefully and convincingly makes her case that there have always been reasonable, indeed often brilliant, people who were not at all sure that technology was solving more problems than it created." --This text refers to the Paperback edition.

Product Description

From the cars we drive to the instant messages we receive, from debate about genetically modified foods to astonishing strides in cloning, robotics, and nanotechnology, it would be hard to deny technology's powerful grip on our lives. To stop and ask whether this digitized, implanted reality is quite what we had in mind when we opted for progress, or to ask if we might not be creating more problems than we solve, is likely to peg us as hopelessly backward or suspiciously eccentric. Yet not only questioning, but challenging technology turns out to have a long and noble history.

In this timely and incisive work, Nicols Fox examines contemporary resistance to technology and places it in a surprising historical context. She brilliantly illuminates the rich but oftentimes unrecognized literary and philosophical tradition that has existed for nearly two centuries, since the first Luddites?the "machine breaking" followers of the mythical Ned Ludd?lifted their sledgehammers in protest against the Industrial Revolution. Tracing that current of thought through some of the great minds of the 19th and 20th centuries?William Blake, Mary Shelley, Charles Dickens, John Ruskin, William Morris, Henry David Thoreau, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Robert Graves, Aldo Leopold, Rachel Carson, and many others?Fox demonstrates that modern protests against consumptive lifestyles and misgivings about the relentless march of mechanization are part of a fascinating hidden history. She shows as well that the Luddite tradition can yield important insights into how we might reshape both technology and modern life so that human, community, and environmental values take precedence over the demands of the machine.

In Against the Machine, Nicols Fox writes with compelling immediacy?bringing a new dimension and depth to the debate over what technology means, both now and for our future.

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 240 pages
• Publisher: Island Press; 1 edition (October 1, 2002)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 1559638605
• ISBN-13: 978-1559638609
• Product Dimensions: 9.3 x 6.3 x 1.3 inches
• Shipping Weight: 1.7 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 3.7 out of 5 stars See all reviews (7 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #1,016,639 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

  Popular in these categories: (What's this?)

  #92 in	Books > Science > Technology > Technology & Society
  #98 in	Books > Computers & Internet > Business & Culture > Future of Computing

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Against the Machine by Nicols Fox, March 3, 2003

By	Laurie Meunier Graves (Winthrop, Maine USA) - See all my reviews

As I read "Against the Machine: The Hidden Luddite Tradition in Literature, Art and Individual Lives" by Nicols Fox, I was aware of an interesting paradox. In its essence, "Against the Machine" charts the rise of the machine from the Industrial Revolution to the present and explores the resistance of workers (the original Luddites), writers, artists, and thinkers to this development. While attempting to be fair minded (and, for the most part, succeeding), Ms. Fox asks whether we have lost more than we have gained. For years, I have wondered the same thing, and I found myself in complete sympathy with Ms. Fox. Yet without machines, and their father-technology-"Against the Machine" would not exist. From its subject matter to its actual physical state-that is, of being a book-"Against the Machine" is totally dependent on machines.

What's a neo-Luddite to do? One option is to buy an island off the coast of Maine, build a small cabin, and live as simply as possible with no electricity, telephone, or central heating. In the first chapter of "Against the Machine," Ms. Fox writes of Nan and Arthur Kellam, who did that very thing. As Nan put it, "[they wanted] to leave behind the battle for non-essentials and the burden of abundance to build in the beauty of this million-masted island a simple home and an uncluttered life." And this they did for forty years. The story ends sadly. Arthur dies, and Nan becomes ill and has to leave their beloved island. Yet, isn't that how all stories inevitably end? No one lasts forever. In the meantime, Nan and Arthur Kellam lived lightly and simply and deliberately.

What modern-day commuter, racing between work, home, errands, and children, hasn't longed for at least some measure of the Kellams' peaceful lives? But, alas, there aren't enough islands for everyone, and most of us must resign ourselves to lives that fall short of such romantic tranquility. However, that doesn't mean we have to concede defeat and use machines mindlessly. And more importantly, we can consider the questions that Ms. Fox asks, "what, after all, is technology? Is it a simple screw? Is it the wheel? Is it a printing press? Is it nuclear fission? ...To think seriously about technology, it will be necessary to examine the nature of mechanical innovation..."

Ms. Fox does this with a vengeance. After the idyllic first chapter with the Kellams, Ms. Fox plunges us into the heart of manufacturing England in the 1800s and chronicles the struggles between the factory owners and the workers. Almost from the start, the story is ugly, with the owners obsessed with profits and quotas while the workers desperately try to maintain standards and not become obsolete. Downsized was not a term that was used back then, but with each mechanical innovation, the workers felt it keenly, even if they didn't know the word.

Ned Ludd, or King Ludd, a figure who was perhaps a blend of myth and reality, became the symbol around which the workers rallied, and in the end, gave them their Luddite name. Secretive, subversive, and akin to Robin Hood, Ned Ludd, in spirit if not in body, ran with the workers when in frustration, they began to smash the machines that were replacing them and producing inferior goods. The workers' protests were not against the machines themselves but rather on the machines' negative effects on their work and on their livelihoods.

According to Ms. Fox, as a result of rampant industrialization, the workers faced poverty, hunger, dislocation, and, if they were lucky enough to keep their jobs, hellish hours. There was no safety net to help the displaced workers, no rent subsidies or food stamps or fuel assistance. When we think of the horrors of Victorian England, we must remember the system that produced these horrors-namely capitalism run amok. The mill owners did not care about the workers; all they cared about was making a profit. The government did not care about the workers, either.

Eventually, the rebellion was quelled, and the workers settled into a new, grinding routine that didn't improve until the rise of the unions. But others continued the struggle. In a clear, concise, and lively style, Ms. Fox moves from the Luddites to the Romantic poets, from the Victorian novelists to the Pre-Raphaelites, from the transcendentalists to the environmentalists, from novelists to those who went back to the land. Ms. Fox's knowledge and range is incredible, and her vivid writing turns what could have been a long and potentially dull list that consists mainly of-let's face it-white men, into a series of fascinating profiles.

Best of all, "Against the Machine" makes the reader think deeply about machines and their place in society. Like all good books, it is a starting point that encourages further reflection. As I thought about the way machines have been used since the industrial revolution, I began to realize how things have shifted. Once, land was used as a source of power and domination, but the machine age changed that, and now technology is used in that way. It's the same old story, except the stakes are higher; we have the ability to destroy the whole planet.

Does it have to be this way? I'd like to think that it doesn't. I'd like to think that we could use machines to make life more comfortable but that we would also have enough sense not to be dominated by them and by those who are in power. I'd like to think we have the ability to say, "Enough! We don't always need more." So far we haven't, but the day may come when our very survival depends on it.

Until then, we need writers such as Nicols Fox to remind us that where we've been is intimately connected with where we are now. And that we have a choice.

24 of 26 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Against the machine connects the dots, December 31, 2002

By	Earl Brechlin (Bar Harbor, Maine United States) - See all my reviews

Always harbored some suspicion about the "march of technology?"
The author of Against the Machine, The Hidden Luddite Tradition in Literature, Art, and Individual Lives, wants to share with you the reason why.
Bass Harbor, Maine author Nicols Fox, who shocked the nation and the world with revelations on bacterial contamination in processed food in her expose, "Spoiled," begins with the social forces that prompted Ned Ludd and his followers to take up arms and traces humanity's love-hate relationship with technology across the next two centuries. Along the way she discovers a deep and broad suspicion about mechanization, industrialization and globalization that permeates art, literature, and politics. As she points out there are many among us who worry, as writer and naturalist Henry David Thoreau said, we are becoming "tools of our tools."
While for some people the premise of this book might make an interesting outline for a lengthy magazine piece, such as those in the Economist for which Ms. Fox frequently writes, she has taken it to the next level and beyond. She has conducted exhaustive research and a broad range of reading to weave together an impressive text that carries the thread of Luddism from those first violent clashes in the early 1800s, through the writings and works of famous artists such as William Blake, Rachael Carson, Edward Abbey, E.B. White, Thoreau, Ralph Waldo Emerson, David Brower, Edouard Manet, Charlie Chaplin, William Morris and John Muir.
Along the way Ms. Fox brilliantly manages to tap into the repressed fears harbored by many modern people who feel disconnected while daily using technology, which we seldom understand and tends to isolate us and remove us further and further from the earth, the weather, each other, and, in the end, our own humanity.
And, Ms. Fox, who, in an ironic twist, operates a Luddite bookstore on the Internet, shows us that the push to preserve the natural world is also another manifestation of Luddite philosophy. "Preserving American's wild land against the utilitarian view and its conjoined twin, economic reality, is the same battle the Luddites fought," Ms. Fox writes.
She also helps dispel some common stereotypes that those that eschew modernity, such as the Unabomber, tend to live reclusively or hate society. "Some anarchists are Luddites but the original Luddites were not anarchists," she writes. "They eventually were forced into a violent expression of their frustration but it was not their intention to bring down the system."
Throughout "Against the Machine," Ms. Fox illustrates her points with vignettes from Maine where, she points out, Luddism is alive and well.
She devotes her first chapter to Art and Nan Kellam's cabin on Placentia Island off Tremont, gives considerable space to Scott and Helen Nearing and also peoples her book with other familiar names and faces including Robert and Diane Phipps of Bar Harbor and Bill Coperthwait, "the yurt guy."
As technology continues to clog our lives, from the incessant television advertisements to the newspaper circulars that tout a seemingly endless array of small electronic devices we don't need and can never hope to learn how to fully operate, it is certain that the ranks of those who consider themselves a least some degree of a Luddite will continue to grow. In connecting the dots and showing us the larger picture of how unease with technology has permeated our society, and bringing the topic to the surface where it can be fully aired, Ms. Fox has done us all a great service. You know when you find yourself saying to yourself "you know, she's right," when you are reading "Against the Machine," she's on to something.
For those who want to divest themselves of the trappings of the machine the first step can be quite simple really. It's as easy as picking up a copy of "Against the Machine," turning off the TV or radio, and enjoying a good read.

8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars A Great Insight Into The Control Modern Life Has Over Us, April 5, 2005

By	gulfjc (California, US) - See all my reviews

Nicols Fox has pinpointed so many key items as to why modern life can be so frustrating for so many of us, and why it is so difficult for us to understand the reasons why.

One main reason is that the history of the 'machine control' goes back way before our own lifetimes, and so we are often unaware of what life might be like without that degree of machine control we all currently live with. The roots go back to the start of the Enlightenment and the Industrial Revolution, where over-rationalised 'reason' and 'calculation' started to assume an increasing degree of respectability over moral values. The moral premise that just because you are powerful or 'able' to do something, you should not necessarily actually do it, effectively went out of the window. Children were sent down coal mines and were made to work in factories for 16 hours a day, and so on. It took Acts of Parliament to eventually outlaw such extreme examples of control, but the overwhelming force to treat people simply as calculated units of production continued. We see the machine operating in everyday life today, where so-called "restaurants" (some fast-food joints) are more similar to factories, and where the staff have their hand movements calculated down to the 1/10th of a second and their words exchanged with customers often have to come from a script. Human input is no longer required by so many workers, simply the mechanistic following of prescribed steps to the nth degree, a wholly dehumanising process.

This dehumanisation of people can lead to frustration, anger, or even violence, with people really not understanding why. It also leads to a society where people as consumers have become totally dependent or "addicted" to factory-made items which their parents used to produce themselves. Home cooking is a great example, where on Thanksgiving Day in the US Emergency 'Hot Lines' are set up on TV channels for people who still feel the need to cook a turkey and celebrate their tradition, but who have absolutely no idea how to do it any more. Calls come from people who have put a totally frozen 14lb turkey, still in its shrink wrap in the oven at 500 degF, and are wondering if that was the right thing to do. The reason being is that modern TV dinners and junk food have taken away people's need to practice the basic human skill and have the dignity of cooking their own meals. So many have become dependent on "ordering-in" a pizza every night, or microwaving pre-packaged food, never even knowing how a vegetable grows or where chickens come from. In short people have become addicted and dependent on technologies which take their money, in a similar way as with drugs, just less extreme, with little or no knowledge or vison of how to become 'undependent' and have the freedom to choose whether to buy the factory-made product, or not.

I think this book 'Against the Machine' by Nicols Fox is a fantastic contribution to a vision of human freedom where people can make better choices in their lives, and not have to be so dependent on 'The Machine' in life's many facets.

Other books I would recommend along similar, but not exactly the same lines are:

1. "Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed" by James Scott ISBN: 0300078153

2. "The Old Way of Seeing (And How to Get It Back)" by Jonathan Hale ISBN: 039574010X . This book has been out of print and is quite expensive, so it's worth looking at second hand booksellers too.