Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
43 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An important work that clearly and succintly makes the case., October 13, 2006
Bringing the credibility of her many years of public service, most notably her work as a Congresswoman during the Watergate Committee and as a prosecutor, Elizabeth Holtzman, with Cynthia Cooper, has produced an important work that is, at the same time, both lawyerly and accessible. They provide the reader with the background - both historical and legal - of the important role of impeachment in the maintenance of our democratic system and then proceed to seamlessly lay out the evidence that overwhelmingly supports their conclusion. While I may not have been the hardest person to sell on their conclusion, the argument is so well-drawn that it is hard to imagine that anyone approaching the book with an open-mind wouldn't come away thinking that impeachment is a necessity or, at least, an option that needs to be explored more in the public discourse.
The most amazing (and, unfortunately, troubling) point made so well by this book is how close the parallel is between the behavior and attitude toward our democratic principles of the current White House and that of Nixon Administration. All the elements that moved the impeachment process after Watergate exist now: dishonesty in proceeding with military action, illegal electronic surveillance of American citizens, the retaliation against persons who challenge the Administration's actions, and the contempt of Congress and the democratic process. Add to those the additional factor that President Bush has demonstrated a total disregard for human life in his irresponsible execution of an unwinnable war and his failure to respond effectively to the devestation created by Hurricane Katrina and it is clear, as was the case over thirty years ago, that action needs to be taken.
As Ms. Holtzman and Ms. Cooper point out, the necessity to act comes not only from the need to remove the President from office, but, also, the need to send the message to all future Presidents (one that should have been clear from the Watergate years) that the disregard of our Constitution and laws will never be tolerated. It is for that reason alone that every person needs to read this book.
|
|
|
25 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Illuminating volume about Bush and impeachment, September 20, 2006
Elizabeth Holtzman and Cynthia Cooper have produced an illuminating and vitally important book about the impeachment process, explaining clearly the case for impeaching President Bush. The book is very readable and, in describing the history and standards for impeachment, shows why impeachment is especially needed now.
I was very impressed by the chapters explaining Bush's personal responsibility in the torture scandals; his reckless indifference to human life in Katrina during which, according to the book, he -- and he alone -- could have mobilized all of the federal resources, but did not; and, his astonishing deceptions leading to the war in Iraq. The book shows how democracy itself will be damaged unless President Bush is held accountable.
Holtzman's experience in Congress during Watergate and the impeachment of Nixon, and Cynthia Cooper's contribution as an author, lawyer and journalist make this an extremely valuable book. Definitely recommend it.
|
|
|
23 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
What we all should know!, November 13, 2006
George W. Bush has turned his presidency into one continuous scandal. If it were not for his six year tenure with a Republican controlled Congress he would already have been impeached.
This is an excellent and well researched book--one that should be read by anyone who considers him or herself to be a true patriotic American.
It would also serve one well to balance the severity of the actions that George W. Bush and his administration have had on America vs. the actions of Bill Clinton and the Clinton Administration.
Hopefully the United States can begin to enjoy a breath of fresh air now that Congress is controlled by the Democratic Party.
My congratulations to Elizabeth Holtzman for a wonderfully informative and worthwhile literary contribution.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|