Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
27 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another Great Volume in A Great Series, April 18, 2005
This book constitutes the third in a proposed 25 volume series setting out the entire history of the Peanuts comic strip (this book covers the years 1955 and 1956). I have reviewed the first two books of the series and had nothing but great things to say about these books. The presentation of this new volume is great as always (with a surprise of Pig Pen making the cover). If you have read Peanuts strip books over the years, a lot more of these strips are going to be familiar to you than the previous two books as many of these strips have been published many times over the years. But there are still plenty of strips that you probably haven't seen in this book that should bring a smile to your face.
You'll see in this book Linus mature from a toddler to the well-spoken and intelligent character he was for the strips 40+ remaining years. Snoopy truly becomes "Snoopy" with his thought balloons and imagination taking over (the imitations of Violet, Lucy, a moose and Mickey Mouse are dead on). Schroeder assumes the straight man role from Shermy, whose role is significantly reduced in these two years. Lucy becomes the world champion fussbudget (with an impressive library of books on fussing for research). Charlie Brown becomes Charlie Brownier as his losing ways magnify during this time (with the highlight being Lucy's first pulling of the football strip).
As with the previous volumes, there are some strips presented of lower quality due to the fact the publishers haven't been able to find good qulity strips for reproduction. I can live with this so long as they have something.
My only complaint about the series is that two volumes a year just isn't fast enough! That will mean the last volume will be published in the spring of 2016!
On a final note, to the first reviewer, I did read somewhere that there is a good chance there will be a box set that will contain this volume plus the fourth volume to be published in the fall, so keep checking Amazon (it isn't listed now).
|
|
|
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Touches My Memory, May 21, 2005
Anyone who is reading this doesn't really need to be told the joys of Peanuts; otherwise you wouldn't have bought this book. And the joys of these little volumes are legion, from the introductions by various writers (this time Matt Groening of Simpsons fame) to the comic strips themselves. Overall, this volume, covering 1955-1956, is another triumph.
The only reason I wanted to make a particular comment about this volume is that, for the first time, I read strips that I knew. Granted, I wouldn't even be born for more than a decade so I never saw these strips in their first run but this is part and parcel of the Peanuts story. When I was a kid and I visited my grandmother's house, she had paperbacks containing old Peanuts strips. I don't even remember the titles, but I remember the strips: they all starred Snoopy and they showed him impersonating other animals (like the python) and other characters (like Lucy). All these strips are in this volume.
In the previous two volumes my key joy had been seeing the beginning and reading strips I had never seen before. In this volume there was still some of that but my overriding feeling was that of visiting my grandmother's house when I was a kid. It is a nice feeling.
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
More familiar material, yet every bit as fascinating!, June 21, 2005
Third "verse," same as the first and the second... well, sort of. As in the first and second volumes, TCP V3 serves up straightforward, black-and-white, chronological helpings of the daily and Sunday Peanuts strips, with a celebrity introduction (by Matt Groening, in this case), a generic Schulz mini-bio, and a useful (but somewhat incomplete) index tacked on for good measure. As in the second volume, some of the previously unreprinted strips do not reproduce well because of low-quality source material (though the fuzziness seems a little less pronounced than in V2, perhaps because there were more client papers to choose from by this time). The one big difference this time around: Many of these strips will be recognizable to long-time Peanuts fans. We are now standing on the edge of an immense ocean of heavily reprinted material from the strip's true glory days, and so there will be fewer surprises in store for those seeking the new and unfamiliar. It will be interesting to see how mass-market sales are affected by this shift.
Not that there aren't a goodly number of "Ooh, I never knew THAT" moments in this collection. Schulz started to work direct pop-culture references into his work at about this time -- many Peanuts fans may recall a strip or two in which Charlie Brown wears a Davy Crockett hat, or Snoopy imitates "Msssp Mssspe" (Mickey Mouse) - but until now, I wasn't aware of how many of them there actually were. You'll find references to Miss Frances (of "Ding Dong School"), Howdy Doody, impending satellite shots, Duke Snider, American agricultural policy, missile defense, sci-fi movies, the mid-50s "pink and charcoal" fashion fad, and numerous riffs on the Crockett phenomenon. (Charlie Brown, surrounded by Crockett merchandise, is moved to cry, "Where will it all end?" - and by volume's end, characters are wondering whatever happened to ole Davy what's his name.) There might even be some references to then-popular ad campaigns that I haven't yet been able to identify. Schulz was a creative genius independent of any outside influences, but he was evidently willing to hang gags on ephemera almost from the beginning.
During this period, Charlie Brown really began to mutate into the "Rats/Good grief/I can't stand it" "eternal loser" we all know and love. In these early days, though, his constant whining about how no one likes him, how inept he is, etc. can get on one's nerves. He has not yet acquired the *Sigh*-laden fatalism of later years and can often react quite violently and emotionally when he is thwarted, frustrated, or just feeling depressed. In this volume, Schulz really puts Charlie through the wringer in three agonizing "continued" stories: his first losing fight against a not-yet-kite-eating-but-certainly-kite-absorbing tree, his first really big failure in a baseball game, and his failure to receive a Christmas card (he is ultimately reduced to going out and buying himself one). Rest assured, he does not take any of these misfortunes well. Also remember that it was this version of Charlie that first attracted many readers to the strip. Postwar angst, anyone? Thankfully, you need no neuroses to continue to enjoy this marvelous project. It's a must purchase for anyone who loves great cartoonery and American pop culture.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|