|
|
60 of 62 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The audience is the thing, January 8, 2000
This book is intended for a certain audience, and for that audience this book largely succeeds. If you have little knowledge of web design and basic graphical concepts, there are few books on the market which equal Weinman for her general advice. More advanced web authorers may well be able to pick apart the code she gives here as faulty in some regards, but for a general overview of basic concepts, she's hard to beat. I found her discussion of color use and image resolution to be particularly helpful at the time I read it, even though now I might regard that information as terribly basic. Weinman has a unique gift, I think, for teaching, and I found her writing style engaging, even if there were, as has been stated elsewhere, a few contentual errors. Of course, we're at a different point in web development than we were when this book was written almost a year ago. Now, many company websites give you much of this information as a part of their websites. Macromedia in particular has much of the advice of this book for free on its website--if you look for it. Who, then, should buy this book? I think if you have a less-than-stellar web connection, or have problems spending hours reading text from websites, or simply do better learning from a real book, this is a great starting point. Also, if you see teachers as fallible individuals whose value is principally in their ability to inspire less than in the absolute precision of their facts, this is your book as well. And if you want a great collection of well-organized references from which to continue your learning, this, too, is where you want to start. Weinman has saved her readers--especially those with slow ISPs--the bother of scouring the net for valuable design resources. There are hundreds of top-notch graphic design web sites listed here by content, which can well save you HOURS of searching if you have a slow web connection, or if your searching skills aren't what they might be. To be sure, there's valid criticism to make of this book. However, <designing web graphics.3> has so much potential applicability that a simple panning of it is entirely undeserved. If you know your way around any Macromedia(-like) product, you probably would think of this as a 1-star kind of book. But if, like its intended audience, you don't know a JPG from a hole in the wall, this is a 5-star effort.
|