From Publishers Weekly
A nobleman unwittingly marries a beautiful creature of the sea. "Lustrous as a pearl," said PW in a starred review of this novel inspired by a 19th-century German fairy tale. Ages 12-up.
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 6-8–Osborne has revised her fairy-tale adaptation of the legend of Undine (Candlewick, 1994), making language and stylistic changes. Lord Huldbrand meets and becomes enamored of a fey marine maiden. Trouble comes upon their marriage when Undines difficulties in adjusting to a terrestrial life and Huldbrands inabilities to fully trust his wifes magical origins bring tragedy to them both. Osbornes straightforward tale exhibits some superb writing. Of Undine, Huldbrand says, She was my axis: whether I was brushing my horse or whittling my bow, I located my heart with her. The descriptions of Undines relationship with the sea are equally evocative, while short, declarative sentences and first-person narration reinforce its inescapable, tragic conclusion. Unfortunately, the spare writing causes the pacing to suffer slightly; the unvarying sentence structure is somewhat stilted, although Osbornes tale is more successful than flawed. Audience is another question. The storys theme of marriage and betrayal is too sophisticated for Osbornes Magic Tree House series (Random) readers, but the tales atmospheric chivalry makes it a hard sell for mainstream middle school readers. Give this to readers who like ghost stories and Arthurian lore.
–Caitlin Augusta, The Darien Library, CT Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.