Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
34 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Encyclopaedic but uninformative, September 4, 2005
It's rather amazing how a book that has so many facts in it can be so consistently limited in its ability to capture the really important stuff about a place. Two summers ago we used it to pick campgrounds on our trip down the coast from San Francisco to Los Angeles and were disappointed to find coastal campgrounds that rated an "8" on Stienstra's scale, only to find that they were essentially located in the middle of parking lots. True, the book says that the number represents only a "scenic rating," but you'd think that campground's immediate surroundings might merit a mention.
Likewise, I just returned from a trip up north where I'd planned to stay with my two kids at a campground that Stienstra rated a "7" and had a description that stated it was "within easy reach of I-80 yet is in a beautiful setting"... with a "gorgeous stream." In fact it was in such easy reach of the freeway that you could literally see and hear the cars and trucks passing two stone's throws away. Was that mentioned? No. Is that my idea of a campground worth going to? Absolutely not.
If you want a book that simply tells you how to get to a certain campground, what amenities are available, whether dogs are permitted, costs, reservation information, etc., this book is exhaustive in its scope and undoubtedly useful. But don't, don't, don't, rely on it to give you a sense of the place. There are much better books out there for that. One we like: "Northern California's Best Family Campgrounds," by Roland de Wolk (Chronicle Books).
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
You gotta have it!, November 9, 2006
I have owned several editions of this book and have passed the old ones on to family and friends. Just the intro is wonderful for people starting to camp. (Key piece of advise from Tom - Schedule your camping time just like you schedule anything else, otherwise it won't happen.) It's fun to check out nearby campgrounds when you bring the book camping with you. I have enjoyed many nights turning the pages and deciding where to camp next. There are books like this for other states, but the California book is the gold stadard. The book will never be 100% accurate, but that's the nature of the beast. It would be great if this info was on a website with amazon-like feedback and google earth views of the campground, photos and maps -- plus a way to access it all in your car! Until then, this is the best. Get his California Hiking book, too. Thanks for writing them and keeping them up to date, Tom! They have lead to many wonderful, memorable trips and hikes for me, my wife and my camping buddies of various ages over many years.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Comprehensive and personal, August 25, 2006
I can't speak for the person who disagreed with some of the ratings. In my experience, this is an invaluable reference, and the personal descriptions of each campground are extremely helpful. Few references will go the extra mile to provide ratings and personal observations about each site like this one does. It's clear that the author has actually visited most of these sites, which is not always the case. It's a great book, and the anecdotes & camping advice in the introduction are very well-written. This book covers every kind of campsite in California, from hike-in primitive sites to RV parking lots. I highly recommend it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|