Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
234 of 244 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Fun in its way but disappointing; not at all what I expected, December 30, 1999
By A Customer
Nowhere on Amazon's page for this book is it made clear that this is first of all a tiny book physically--tiny novelty trim size, not many pages. The price for this tiny book is not correspondingly tiny. More to the point, the book is a quickie impulse-buy type book, made up entirely of very brief (one- to several-sentence) quips, comments, witticisms, and pieces of advice about men's style, three or four of these to a page. Some of these tips are helpful, though the entire text is heavily pervaded with Esquire's, or the authors', elitist attitudes, the assumption seeming to be that every man has it within his means to buy a $1,000, or even a $500, suit. What I had wanted (and expected to find here) was a book comprised of traditional text and chapters that would go into detail on the subject of men's clothing and style. THIS depth of information from Esquire would have been very interesting to me. In the end, I gleaned some helpful knowledge from this book (which I read in about fifteen minutes), but I am back again at Amazon's pages, looking for the kind of book I wanted in the first place.
|
|
|
37 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Entertaining, dogmatic (ha), and moderately useful, May 2, 2003
This book should never take the place of a truly useful guide to timeless style like, say, Alan Flusser's Clothes and the Man: The Principles of Fine Men's Dress. But for summarizing the things a man shouldn't do, getting him to actually start thinking about style, or saying things that really need to be said ("No level of fitness justifies wearing a tank top in public" [p. 80].), this little guide is a pretty good way to get started.
Perhaps in keeping with the entertaining bulldog photos that break up the text, some of the declarations are somewhat too dogmatic: No cowboy boots, no Hawaiian shirts, no pleated khakis. In fact, there's some room for discussion on most of these issues (what if you live in Hawaii?). But frankly, so many men need so much help dressing properly that if they need absolute rules to live by, so be it.
On the whole, this is a very entertaining little book. If men turn to magazines like Esquire (2-year) for their style guidance, then I wish a handy primer like this one all success in imparting a few guiding principles. But the most useful principle of all may be the one they print about a dozen pages from the end: "Never trust a fashion magazine."
|
|
|
29 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A complete waste of time and money, October 10, 2000
This is probably a good example of how dangerous online shopping may sometimes be. I would never would have bought this book, had I had the chance to glimpse at it in a real store. So far this is my worst online purchase. Here are the reasons. It's not really a book - it's a collection of dim-witted aphorisms related to men's fashion. There is an average of 4 such phrases per page ("The Hawaiian shirt: no" or "Expensive shampoo smells really good") x 150 pages = 600 common sense proverbs in all. Basically this book is good for men who have absolutely no clue about fashion (Ricki Lake makeover candidates), as the first stepping stone. If you already know that socks are a must and that sneakers don't go with suits, you will be as disappointed as I am now.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|