Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
27 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not for Beginners, December 21, 2005
I will try to strike a balance to the previous two reviews. This cookbook is beautiful. It is a large outsized book that will cause people with cookbook holders possible issues but if you have Glazer's _Artisanal Baking in America_ the size should not surprise.
I got this book the first day it was released and have spent the time reading and cooking from it.
1) the recipes are excellent. However, some of the ingredients will be hard and expensive to come by such as sand dabs which are easy on the west coast to get but quite the adventure in the midwest;
2) the recipes are not for beginners. You must have basic, competant skills not to mention maybe some specialized tools to make your life easier such as, a food processor or food mill. If you are hoping for super simple ingredients and expect to have a dinner party done in a few hours this may not be the book for you. The recipes are doable with planning and careful reading;
3) Very west coast, in particular, Northern California. Nancy Oakes and her restaurant Boulevard have been part of the cutting edge providing fresh takes on classics and loving attention to local ingredients.
4) The book is beautiful and could grace a coffee table with gorgeous pictures of food, staff and surroundings. However, sometime I felt that the design of the book took greater precedence than ease of reading and use for the cook. An example is how there is a great deal of white space but the typeface (8-10 pt) is more typical of regular sized cookbooks;
5) I have been a long time fan of her husband, Bruce Aidell, the sausage king, and in his books always had contributions from Nancy that truly showcase meat in all its glory including brining. However, when you read this book you see the expertise with meat but not to the level that I would expect from Ms. Oakes as evidenced from the contributions to her husband's books.
6) The meals are showstoppers. What meal was NOT a showstoppper? Yeah, I'm getting plumper but my figure was sacraficed on a mighty tasty and good looking altar
7) Each recipe is presented this way: main recipe with attendant side items that compose that course. Yes, this includes the salads which have the recipes for the garnishes and accompaniements on the same page. So quite frankly, having multiple courses can be quite the production for it is not just "white corn soup" but the single corn stock, garnish and crab cake souffles. Like I said, not for beginners or someone wanting a meal in 30 minutes.
8) recipes can be modified and adapted easily. So I did not have tiny quail for the buttermilk fried recipe but it did translate very well to chicken and the same for brining the guineau hens. Again, chicken came to rescue. So if you are freaking out about making everything just take the parts that you like
In all, an excellent book. Just remember that this book is not for beginners but people who can plan and have some basic skills.
Highly recommended for the collector and for those who love Northern California cuisine. And if you are wondering where I stand on the debate of Chez Panisse vs. Boulevard? Boulevard because no body does meat/fish/poultry as well.
|
|
|
36 of 46 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Warning - you will feel inferior, January 14, 2006
Now that I have your attention, I'd like to seriously warn you about expecting this book to be a cookbook you might use. It is a collection of marvelous presentations, but unless you have a full professional kitchen, a couple of sous-chefs hanging around, and are the kind of person who loves to spend a week preparing the basic ingredients for an upcoming meal, this book should be enjoyed as a wonderful commercial for the restuarant, and not as a cookbook. Every "recipe" is a full blown presentation (see other review listing); a base preparation, under the star presentation supported by a cast of at least two if not three co-stars. And if you try to just make one of the items, I'm afraid you'll end up feeling inferior that you didn't prepare the full meal deal.
Lovely photographs, by the way.
Get the book from the library, save your money to take a trip to SF and eat at the restaurant. That's what I should have done.
|
|
|
22 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
4 and a half, really. Very good foodie book. Good reading., February 8, 2006
`Boulevard, The Cookbook' is the product of co-chefs, Nancy Oakes and Pamela Mazzola plus professional culinary writer, Lisa Weiss. The restaurant, Boulevard is in the San Francisco Bay area and the second of two restaurants headed up by Oakes and Mazzola. The overall impression I get of the ambiance and the recipes is that Boulevard is a brasserie with a `haute cuisine' attitude and an underpinning of a love of bacon. The love of bacon is entirely understandable, as Nancy Oakes is the wife of the American Pork writer in chief, Bruce Aidells, with whom she has co-authored several books on pork cookery and charcuterie.
When I encounter an oversized cookbook volume with an oversized price (listed at $50), I immediately demote the book's overall score to four stars, unless I find within a truly marvelous source of culinary wisdom. As I write this, I am teetering on the boundary of four and five stars, so we will investigate together how to rate this volume.
To start, I give points for the fact that the table of contents lists the name and page number of every single recipe. Of course, since the book has only 48 recipes, this is no great feat, covering no more than three of the oversized pages. To be fair, the 15 main dish recipes and the soups actually contain recipes for major garnishes or veggie side dishes. If you broke out all the secondary recipes, you may have as many as 60 different dishes. There are also 27 recipes in the `Blvd Basics' chapter, but as these are mostly for things such as stocks, sauces, condiments, and stock garnishes, these hardly count. I don't discount them entirely because I am in love with the idea from Deborah Madison that stocks and other utility recipes should be crafted to fit the dishes in which they are used, so it is important for us to know exactly how it is that Boulevard makes their duck confit to say with accuracy that you are making a `Boulevard recipe' which uses duck confit. It may also be worth noting that some of these recipes are actually served at the authors' other restaurant, L'Avenue and some are actually things they really cook at home.
The main chapters are:
Salads, 6 recipes
Soups, 6 recipes
Starters, 13 recipes
Fish, 7 recipes
Meat, 8 recipes
Desserts, 8 recipes
Since four of the six soups, the white corn coup, the ratatouille soup, the chestnut soup, and the Provencal fish soup (Bouillabaisse) are simply fancy versions of very old standards, we can ask ourselves why should we want to make these versions, when we may have three recipes for corn soup, a dozen recipes for ratatouille, at least three recipes for a chestnut soup, and 20 recipes for a Bouillabaisse (and still no source for Racasse!)? Especially since most of the recipes are really very long. While my favorite Mark Bittman corn soup recipe takes about a half page column in `How to Cook Everything', this white corn soup with `little crab cake `souffles' takes two oversized pages, with four different recipes coming together to make one dish. Similarly, my favorite David Boulud chestnut soup with apples takes but one page, this braised chestnut soup with apple cream and crispy duck confit takes another two pages. And, while chestnuts and duck confit are a natural pairing in southwest France, they are less natural denizens of Napa valley or Santa Clara valley.
To be fair, a considerable amount of space in each of these recipes goes to a rhapsodic headnote about the origins of the dish plus `Kitchen and Shopping Notes' which go into where the restaurant buys and preps its chestnuts, seafood, artichokes and mayonnaise. We learn, for example, that artichokes come packaged like shrimp, with a count per unit carton packaging. And, we learn that the restaurant is perfectly happy using Hellmans / Best Foods mayonnaise off the shelf rather than making it themselves.
It should be obvious that this cookbook is a lot more like Thomas Keller (The French Laundry) and Judy Rodgers' (Zuni Café) efforts than the much more straightforward fish restaurant books by Eric Ripert (Le Bernardin) and Thomas Kinkead (Kinkead's) books. Thus, it is to be read more as a source of inspiration and ideas and maybe a dish for some very special entertaining occasion than as a workaday cookbook. Of course, this is also the kind of book that a patron of Boulevard would be very happy to have.
When compared to books by Keller and Rodgers, this book fares well, but it is probably not better than these two exemplars of the `great restaurant' book. But, if you buy this kind of book, this is definitely one you will want. If you buy `great restaurant' books for cooking tips and insights, this book is good, but not great. I encountered a lot of things I already knew and no major new insight. So, the fewer books of this type you have, the more valuable this one will be. If you have a big cookbook library, the margin of value will be small.
Since the book makes excellent use of some distinctly west coast seafood such as Dungeness crab, California white sea bass, and king salmon, the marginal value is also higher for west coasters than us Yankees or even our Johnny Reb cousins on the east coast.
Of course, all the recipes are very well detailed, look great in sumptuous pics, and, I'm sure, taste great. There are even a few, such as the scallop and squid recipes, which may just be simple enough for you to improvise into your own repertoire.
All in all, this is a very good, but not a great foodie book.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|