Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
outdated but might be helpful to some., July 4, 2000
One might think, looking at the 1999 publishing date and the publisher's description that King's translation is among the most recent. If so, one will be sorely disapointed upon reading this book. This is a reprint of King's 1902 translation of the Enuma Elish, the Assyro-Babylonian creation myth. In the intervening years, additional copies of the text have been discovered, filling in most of the gaps found in King's translation and correcting his tenative translations of lines that in his day were only partially known. If you are looking for a more complete more updated translation, you'd be much better served with Stephanie Dalley's 1989 work, Myths from Mesopotamia, where you'd also get translations of several other Akkadian language myths. Further off-putting is the one page preface by Paul Tice, which spends more space endorsing the rather questionable theories of Zecharia Sitchin than it does addressing the contents of King's book.There are some useful features in this book though. More than half of the Enuma Elish that King worked with was complete and his translation is presented in parallel with a transliteration of the original Akkadian. There are included additional scholarly essays by King on varying subjects related to the creation story including parallels with Genesis. Some of these essays, are hampered by the lack of available knowledge at the time and for significant portions of them King must make speculations which are no longer justified. Ninety-eight years ago, this must have been one of the more thorough, cutting-edge works on the subject, but so much more has been learned in the mean-time, that I would only recommend this work to those who already have more recent translations of the Enuma Elish.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Quite interesting, February 5, 2002
The highpoint of the ancient Mesopotamian year was the New Year celebrations. It was a time of parties, games and the reading of epic stories. In Nineveh, an important epic was their creation story, which told the story of the creation of the universe, and the rise to preeminence of the god Marduk (Nineveh's patron deity).Though lost for millennia, the seven cuneiform tablets containing the Assyrian creation myth were found in the ruins of Nineveh at the end of the nineteenth century, and were translated by L.W. King in 1902. Although translated so long ago, Mr. King's text is still easy to follow, and is a highly enjoyable read. Unfortunately, since there was only one set of tablets extant in 1902, and that set was damaged, there are holes in the narrative that do somewhat decrease the enjoyment of the story. As a student of Sumerian literature, I must say that I found this Assyrian text quite interesting, showing how the stories changed and evolved as they were passed on to later generations and cultures. I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in ancient Mesopotamia.
|
|
|
|